Over the last few years I’ve had the privilege of listening to players across a very wide gambit of skill, from pros to 1 hour a month scrubs talk about their experiences in the game, both WZ and multiplayer. I also want to separate these observations from my own, personal experience with SBMM.
“I just want a variety of experiences”
I think this is a very valid want, and my preferred experience. I just don’t think that this IS an experience for a majority of players, and that’s why I think complaints fall on deaf ears.
I believe SBMM only really disfavors people in the top 20-25 percent of players, the rest see a net improvement in experience over random matchmaking.
“They should practice and get better”
Probably the most common rebuttal to SBMM, but ultimately it’s a self defeating argument. This is reductio ad absurdum, the idea that everyone can simply just “get good” to avoid the need for mechanical skill sorting and have a positive overall experience lends itself to self create a natural SBMM, but only the top tier exists.
When everyone is special nobody is, and that’s not a great experience either.
“Sub you’re just a bot who needs SBMM”
Well, bot, maybe. But I sit in that skill bracket where SBMM hurts me more than most: I’m not skilled enough to hang with the top dawgs, but I’m too skilled to slip into the safe harbor of lower Skill Based Matchmaking.
Do I want SBMM in my lobbies? No.
Do I understand why it’s there? Yes.
Do I think there’s a great answer here?
Honestly, not really.
My 2 cents: SBMM means you keep playing the same game against the same people (ie people who play the same way and the skill as you even if they are different players) so the games lack diversity especially when the constant challenge keeps players playing the meta instead of diversifying their load outs. You also never feel your self get better because the games are always the same difficulty. As you get better so does everyone in your lobbies. There is more to it of course. Ranked is a great place for SBMM but in pubs I'd rather play against a diversified lobby. Generally there will be some people better than you and some worse. And for me that is what made older CoDs more fun because SBMM was minimal.
New leak:
GTA VII: Portland: Jason & Lucia escaped Vice City for the quiet suburbs. They got the house, the picket fence, and Amazon Prime. They did not get peace.
@favestar_ Damn this timeline. Taylor Lorenz is probably one of the most morally bankrupt, uneducated, and corrupt “ journalists” in the American media landscape. Possibly one of the worst all-time.. and here I am agreeing with her.
It’s interesting because it’s actually because Bonnie and Clyde are such an easy parallel that the game struggles. The motivations behind a Bonnie and Clyde are very much in line with what makes a good GTA game. Putting the kid as the focal point behind Jason and Lucia’s motivation is a huge fault of the story.
1: This isn't my wife. I don't want to fix up someone else's girls house or fetch her flowers.
2: Five hours in and she hasn't earned shit from me. From what I can tell, the only thing she's brought to the table is the fact that she skipped out on this dude with his kid and got herself pinched.
Him bending over backwards for the hot crazy girl who skipped out on him after a few months is, without question, shitty writing and cuck behavior.
A good writer would have spent Part 1 building the relationship BEFORE she got jailed, so we'd have a reason to care that she's coming back.
@ItsLethalTTV Single player games imo always struggle with this - not everything you do in game is captivating. Grinding levels, searching for some treasure, etc. Single player games are geared around playing vs watching, and that often exposes streamers who aren't great entertainers.
@ObeezyLive There are 312 songs across 2 languages and multiple genres. What, exactly, do you want them to do here for what is likely less than .5% of the player base? One radio station playing cheezy AI slop? Commission an alternate set of stations?
@ItsLethalTTV At current count, there are 312 songs in GTA 6. Trying to produce a comparable, copyright-free version of the experience across all 20 music stations and genres (including ones in Spanish) just doesn't seem practical for such a incredibly small portion of the player base.
@hoffstra323@TXMCtrades According to every other GTA they’ve released: millions. You can torch millions of NPCs before it’s less interesting than putting together IKEA furniture
Pretty spot on, honestly. This game feels like its trying to FORCE morality into a game that, by definition, is devoid of it, and it doesn't fit.
If devs / lawyers don't want behaviors in the game, don't put the assets in there in the first place. If you don't want people to shoot up a gay bar, don't put one in the game. If you don't want people to carjack single women NPCs, don't put them in the game. If you don't want to see liberal protesters run over, don't put them in the game.
The game thrives on the zany, outlandish things you can do in the world. Adding these artificial guardrails breaks the core, fundamental design of the franchise. GTA V opened up everything from rednecks, to tech bros, gangbangers, and everything in between. Nothing in the game was off limits, and that was the formula for the best selling game of all time.
This is the kind of franchise mothers should be writing congress about, not a game about trying to make you a better person.
I mean, I've got like 2 hours on it today, but really don't notice it at all (building a deck doesn't change much beyond about 12fps).
Now if I were to A/B this on my PC (9800x3d / 5080 / 64gb ddr5) I'm sure I'd notice it and it would be an issue. But I don't have that and after a few minutes it's playing fine on the 75".
I wish people would stop making me defend billion dollar businesses and the main stream media this week but at least we got GTA 6 before I did either.
This guy @momozuch is basically correct.
Traditionally the glossy print gaming media needed access and ad dollars. High profile studios often held the keys for both: if you want access to early copies, devs & execs (beyond the PR wall everyone could access), and you wanted premium ad spend, you played ball. That economy is more or less obsolete, and a company like Rockstar, quite frankly, doesn't release games often enough to leverage the average beat writer from GTAV one way or the other. Activision or EA are different stories as they release much more frequently, but for GTA6, anyone they canceled 13 years ago isn't likely to be relevant, much less in the industry at all at this point.
Also, once again, cutting graphics doesn't change the CPU load, so no, a "performance mode" won't get you 60 fps. It'll just get you 30 fps with shitty potato graphics.
As a former games journo I feel compelled to address smooth brained GTA review day takes.
1. Rockstar is not paying media outlets for good reviews. You people always scream about this while ignoring the fact that influencers openly get paid for shit all the time.