What a clean, focused subscription brand.
@Ancestral does an incredible job in making the subscription option obvious, onboarding you to the program, and making updates clear.
This is my video series where we do breakdowns on how brands are acquiring (PDP), onboarding (email) and managing subscription experiences (portal).
Check it out, or access our free resources at https://t.co/WkFvak2v0G
The first 10 to 15 days after delivery are where a new subscriber builds the habit or forgets the box in a cabinet.
Fire the how-to email off the delivery event, not day 25. Tell them how to mix it, what it tastes like, and what they should feel.
What do you diagnose when subscription churn is really high?
There are two halves to the problem.
The first half is how you got the subscriber in. The second half is what they experienced after.
On the first half, the patterns repeat:
- 50% off the first order, then full price at renewal. The jump feels like a bait and switch.
- No one-time purchase option, so people subscribe because they have to.
- A 3-month supply offer placed on a 1-month cadence. Product piles up, and the subscriber cancels.
None of these are email problems. A better win-back flow will not fix a subscriber who never wanted the cadence you put them on.
The second half of the problem is expectation or product experience.
Flavor is bad. Or a key step people are missing.
Or, they expect it to work immediately when it takes weeks.
Expectation setting is the other half of the problem, or product issues.
I’m Thomas. I'm 39. Married, with a 2-y-o son. I wrote the book Retention Economics, and I help ecomm brands scale to 9 figures via retention and LTV.
These are the 4 non-negotiables I implement for every single client:
1) Calculation of Retention Economics
▶︎ LTV, CAC, retention curve shape
▶︎ Payback Period, Delivered Contribution Margin (CM2), Retention Contribution Margin (CM3)
▶︎ Year-1 Retention Efficiency
▶︎ Benchmarks vs. competing brands in their vertical (easy with backend data from 3,000+ US brands)
I nail Retention Economics first. Scaling bad Retention Economics = scaling a liability.
2) Subscription Adoption
▶︎ Subscription-only or subscription-first?
▶︎ At least 2/3 of customers should subscribe (ideal: 85%+)
▶︎ If not, this is the first growth bottleneck I address
3) Higher nAOV
▶︎ Show ONLY a 30-day option on the front end
▶︎ Adding 60- and 90-day options pushes nCAC up
▶︎ Lock in the lowest nCAC, then upsell 60/90 post-checkout (via @Aftersell)
4) Post-Purchase System
▶︎ The first 14 days are an extension of the product, and need to be treated as such
▶︎ LTV is won OR lost in billing cycle #1
▶︎ Expectation-setting, onboarding, & habit-anchoring are all priorities
I’d say we have it down to a science, but it’s really an art.
And there you have it. That's the post.
Monthly churn hides when people leave. Plot cancellations by days since subscribing.
A day 2 spike is offer regret. A day 27 spike on a 30-day plan is the billing reminder. Each one is a separate test.
A 10% discount off the one-time price will get you some subscribers. It will not get you a CAC you can scale on.
Pack the first order with a free second bag, a mug, a how-to kit, whatever makes subscribing the obvious choice instead of buying once.
Unfortunately, this is not true.
While save rate is a great metric to track, a save is no guarantee of another order.
Most brands only see like 10-30% of saves from cancel flows order again, so this is really just delaying the inevitable.
We know this because we dig beyond the surface data for all of our brands and this trend is true across the board.
We see higher retention from saves when customers reschedule their next order or accept a discount / offer.
Skipping is THE WORST action for a subscriber to take, and is way too often misunderstood as “saving” the customer.
Once a customer skips, you may as well treat them like a customer to win back.
Set up a skip recovery flow to push them to “get it now” with an offer that expires soon.
Then start tracking the effective save rate after the save to evaluate the results.
This isn’t to say that your save rate is irrelevant, but it’s important that everyone knows there’s much more to the story than what is on the surface.
I’m just as incentivized as the next guy to say the opposite, but this is just the truth if you want to improve your retention.
🤷♂️
One thing that completely surprised me as a step-parent: how much a kid can completely rewire your brain.
Sure, I've learned to have more patience and communication and all that crap. That's not what I mean.
5 years ago my step-son would say "Is it?" after almost any statement.
"Wear a jacket its cold outside."
"Is it?"
"Time for bed."
"Is it?"
His simple, silly question RUNS IN MY HEAD ALL THE DAMN TIME TO THIS DAY!
Anything someone says and a little voice in my head says "Is it?"
Relgion, politics, work, money... doesn't matter. Nothing is sacred anymore.
Kids. 🙄
"Campaigns drove $50k last month." How much came from subscribers?
Hold new subscribers out of promo sends for 60 days. Compare campaign revenue and month 2 renewal rate. Sometimes the revenue barely moves and retention goes up.
Brands with a great product and no retention tactics often out-retain brands running every tactic on a weak product.
If your monthly cohorts keep sliding after the second order, look at the formula and the taste before you look at the email flows.
cash flow is the goal - to replace salary, to build wealth
Ultimately an exit is a big event with a lot of money that requires a ton of time and sacrifice.
Looking at what you could make elsewhere and compounding the cash over time instead of just an exit is another way to look at what you should do.
We're hiring the person who finds the broken link.
Every email team has one. Everyone else looks at the email and sees an email. This person sees a footer link pointing at last month's sale.
I am not that person. That's why we're hiring.
The role: Klaviyo Specialist at No Limit Email. Part-time, around 20 hours a week, 5 to 7 client accounts, fully remote.
You build the flows, campaigns, segments and pop-ups. You QA every email and SMS before it ships. When a plan won't build cleanly in Klaviyo, you say so and bring the version that will.
Three things to know before you apply:
1. It's hands-on. Managing people who used Klaviyo is a different job.
2. We use Claude and Claude Code every day. If your AI workflow is "I asked it for a subject line once," this will be a shock.
3. You don't need to work US hours. Some overlap with the US morning helps.
The link to apply is in the reply below.
And if you know someone who can't walk past a typo on a restaurant menu, send them this.
There are only three things that matter in subscriptions.
I'm not talking growth hacks, flows, or anything tactical.
Foundational principles that transcend industries, sizes, and markets. The only three things you need to succeed at subscriptions is to be:
1. Product obsessed.
2. Offer obsessed.
3. Obsessed with how customers use the product.
Everything else is noise. Let's break down how those three things should be built: https://t.co/JRVshat0eq
When month 1 churn is 50%, look at the offer before the emails.
50% off then full price at renewal. No one-time option. A 3-month supply on a 1-month cadence. A win-back flow fixes none of these.
Nobody renews a product they never used. On audits I ask whether new subscribers know how to mix it, what it tastes like, or that it might make them jittery, and the answer is often "I'm not sure."
The fix is to map the first two weeks around adoption. Trigger your best-practices email off the delivery event in Shopify, not a calendar date. The first 10 to 15 days after the box lands are your window to get someone activated. An email on day 25 is late.
Subscribe now to get it in your inbox tomorrow (link in the first comment).