I had forgotten about this from Jan. 3, 2017. Here is Chuck Schumer actually saying something prescient. "You take on the intelligence community, they have six ways from Sunday of getting back at ya." -Chuck Schumer
https://t.co/65fxrZyD0k
@NaileZoupani@rich_toronto@grok@elrington1952 You're delusional. I didn't concede anything. I just pointed out why you were wrong. For the record, civilians can be combatants, from time to time, and combatants are legitimate targets. The relevant distinction in war is between combatants and noncombatants.
@waffle_ladders@JasonJournoDC The Daily Wire, presumably. It's almost certainly tax-deductible, though, so it's like half-price after tax. The cost of security is a bigger hit to religious institutions, which are generally tax-exempt.
That and also your lack of empathy for the OP and your claim that the OP was attacking strawmen.
It is practically a tautology that it is reasonable to question our relationship with Israel. Talk about strawmen.
What Vance did was rather explicitly make Israel and its American supporters scapegoats for the midterms. And it did so based on unsubstantiated polling by some anon that is contradicted by just anout every other polling analysis. The fact is our relationship with Israel barely registers with the electorate. It is an obsession for a large segment of podcastistan, but that's because of the obvious grift that even Nick Fuentes identified the other day.
They're all interwined. Perhaps the most egregious part of Vance's tweet is the one where he highlighted our support for Israel being one of the top four reasons for the midterm losses. Objectively, that is ridiculous. You explicitly highlighted that in your response. If you weren't defending Vance's tweet, you have a strange way of making your point.
@juaninathousand@ScipioPersicus2@michelletandler Huh? The OP specifically referenced the Vance tweet, and you impliedly defended it. I think the Vance tweet is indefensible, primarily because it was just made up bullshit.
Declaring war is an anachronism and a redundancy. At the time the Constitition was drafted, we had a minimal standing army, and it took months to gear up for war. A declaration of war by Congress was needed to get the ball rolling and assure contractors, soldiers and creditors they would be paid, but ultimately Congress can regulate a President's ability to wage war through its power of the purse.
And Congress has continued to fund $900B budgets for the Department of War, so it has tacitly and effectively approved of this war or any military activity conducted by the President.
The latter part of your claim is baseless. Even your claim that the PM of Israel is cynical is baseless.
As for being decided on the whim of a crazy old man, well, that's the system of government we have. I suppose things would be better if I were President, but I don't really want the job.
Yes, I do. Midterms are driven by anger and hate, and the Democratic (i.e anti-Trump) turnout was comparable to what you would see in a Presidential election year. Trump's behavior and his in-your-face corruption, from the pardons, to the crypto nonsense, to the business deals with foreign countries, drove anti-Trump sentiment to 11.
As for what you actually said, my understanding is it was in response to the OP worrying that people on the right are blaming the midterm wipeout on the Israel and, as a consequence, Israel's supporters, the most conspicuous of which are Jews (and particularly those on the right). This is what JD Vance's tweet did. Your response implied support for Vance's tweet, which, to be frank, I found to be false and disgusting.
First of all, we shouldn't decide policy by polls, let alone foreign policy. Second, opposition to the Iran war was primarily driven by anti-Trump sentiment on the Left and anti-Israel sentiment on the Right. Third, the Iran war has been prolonged and made more difficult by the kneejerk opposition. Iran takes comfort in that opposition.
If you want to blame Iran primarily for the mid-term losses, rather than, say, Trump's blatant corruption, his focus on trivialities, his backing of weak candidates like Ken Paxton or Lindsey Graham's sister, or erratic behavior and messaging, then perhaps you should also reserve some blame for the antiwar "conservatives" who literally supported not just Democratic candidates but far left ones.
Finally, and most importantly, the hatred of the state of Israel is almost entirely driven by antisemitism. Israel contributes more to our national security than any other country on Earth, by a wide margin. And unless you conflate American Jews with Israel, then you cannot reasonably argue that Israel has undue influence on us. China, Russia, and the Gulf Arab countries (particularly Qatar) have an order of magnitude more influence, and it's malign influence. At least the influence of pro-Israel American Jews is driven out of a genuine belief in aligned strategic interest.