@reubenguttman Agree completely. As a 37-year trial lawyer & former appellate judge who entered academia late in life, my scholarship is aimed at helping lawyers & judges with issues they are either grappling with or soon will be - not theoretical nonsense. Practical writing, not fuzzy.
@nateraymond@EWess92 An equally relevant point is the opposition to the nomination of Gaiser ( who wasn’t vetted by the FJEC and has virtually no TX ties) by conservative TX practitioners in the N.D. who resent the fact that qualified TX judges and lawyers are being passed over for a carpetbagger.
@TheRepLawyer@SenJudiciaryGOP@ElliotGaiser@JudgeSullyTX Did they inexplicably run out of actual Texans to nominate for the N.D.? Of course not - we have an abundance of qualified conservative TX judges and lawyers who have been vetted by the FJEC. Let Mr. Gaiser wait for an Ohio bench; people admitted in TX and the N.D. await.
@HarmeetKDhillon If only he were a Texan! Why is Pres. Trump appointing someone from Ohio with no real ties to TX ( like a TX law license or admission to the court where he wants to preside) to a TX federal court? Did we somehow run out of qualified conservative TX judges and lawyers?
@grantstrobl@ElliotGaiser You’re free to follow him into battle, or to a federal bench in Ohio, where he’s from. Leave the TX federal benches to conservative, qualified TX judges and lawyers who have been vetted by our FJEC and who are supported by BOTH of our U.S. Senators.
@EWess92 “The Texans?” That should be singular, not plural. Justice Sullivan is a Texan. Gaiser is from Ohio. I ate Skyline chili in Cincinnati once - that doesn’t mean I should be on a federal bench in Ohio. Plenty of great TX conservative judges and lawyers insulted by this pick.
@TheElizMitchell@ElliotGaiser Great nomination if this were an Ohio vacancy - but it’s not. He has no ties to TX beyond a Jones clerkship. Not admitted to TX or the N.D. This is an insult to the FJEC and the many qualified TX conservative judges and lawyers. I visited Cincy once; should I be on their bench?
@EWess92 He has no ties to TX, is not admitted to practice in TX or the N.D., and his nomination is an affront to the hard work of the local judicial qualifications committee as well as well-qualified conservative TX state court judges and lawyers.
@courtneybuble I don’t blame him for not issuing any statement of support. Gaiser is not a Texan, not admitted to practice in TX or the N.D., and has no TX ties beyond his clerkship for Judge Jones. What an affront to the many qualified conservative TX state judges and lawyers!
@joshjcraddock@ElliotGaiser If only he were actually a Texan or licensed to practice in TX! What, no vacancies in Ohio? As someone admitted to practice in the N.D. in TX, this is a slap in the face to the many qualified, conservative TX state judges and lawyers, and to the FJEC members.
@LauraEWeiss16@howappealing It is virtually unprecedented to try to ramrod through a nominee for a TX federal bench who is not even a Texan, is not licensed in TX, and has no meaningful connection to TX - especially when there are fine candidates in the TX bench and bar.
@jadler1969 Interesting is one word for it; “ shamefully inappropriate” also comes to mind, for bypassing the work of FJEC members and the many well-qualified conservative TX state court judges and lawyers who merit consideration for a TX federal bench.
@DaveYostOH I don’t feel “passed over”. Our president understandably prefers youth over judicial experience for his lifetime appointments, and wouldn’t be appointing this 60-something year-old former appellate judge. But a clerkship is hardly “ Texas roots”, and Texas has talent right here.