Jinnah explicitly advised Muslims to stay in India not to serve the homeland but to act as a guarantee for Pakistan. The 1946 vote was 87 percent to break the map not to keep it. You do not get a patriot's medal for voting to demolish the house and then staying in the ruins because you missed the train. And coming from a Bangladeshi this lecture is rich. Your ancestors voted for Pakistan then fought a bloody war in 1971 to escape the consequence. You didn't sacrifice for the homeland you voted to destroy it and then got stuck in the debris.
You are confusing immobility with loyalty.
In 1946, 87% of the Muslim electorate voted for the Muslim League. The "Ideology" was Pakistan.
They stayed because of Geography that would distance and Jinnah’s explicit advice to remain as leverage -The Hostage Theory.
Voting to partition the house and then staying in the bedroom because you cannot move the furniture does not make you the owner. It makes you a resident who ran out of options.
Also my dear Eastern neighbour , let me educate you about the Hostage Theory which is documented in Venkat Dhulipala’s Creating a New Medina. It cites Muslim League archives proving this was a core strategy, not an accident. Jinnah and leaders like Shabbir Usmani argued that the Hindu minority in Pakistan would be the guarantee for the safety of Muslims in India, a doctrine of mutual deterrence. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar contemporaneously attacked this as a scheme of communal hostages. The choice to stay wasn't patriotism, it was the strategic placement of human shields.
@VedicWisdom1 Ha ha ha , you blocked @theevosapien . Chill man , reply karo, have a healthy debate . Why are you getting triggered if someone gives you their point of view which is not matching with yours
The interaction has concluded with a classic "ad hominem" retreat.
The account Vedic Wisdom ‘@Vedicwisdom1” attempted to enforce a monolithic dietary restriction on Hinduism using selective citations. When confronted with primary sources—specifically Manusmriti 5.56 (permissibility), Charaka Samhita (meat as food), and the correct grammatical interpretation of Verse 5.52 (Anabhyarcya implies permission with worship)—this guy chose to disengage via blocking rather than debate.
This validates the "Guru" position: the opponent’s theology was fragile and could not withstand scrutiny against the very texts they claimed to represent. Censorship in a theological debate is an implicit concession that one lacks the textual evidence to continue.
Verse 5.52 that you quoted here uses the word anabhyarcya (without worshipping).
This explicitly implies that if you do worship the Gods and Pitrs (Ancestors) eating meat is permitted. This is the distinction between Vritha Mamsa (forbidden) and Prasad (permitted). You just proved that meat eating is allowed under ritual conditions.
Also regarding Ayurveda you are factually wrong. Charaka Samhita Sutrasthana Chapter 27 is titled Annapanavidhi Adhyaya (Chapter on Food and Drink). Meat is listed there under Mamsa Varga as a food group alongside grains and vegetables not in a pharmacy list.
You are attacking the messenger instead of the metric. Goldman defines affluent as an annual income above 10000 dollars. Does that sound low to you? In purchasing power parity terms that buys a lifestyle equivalent to 35000 dollars in Europe. That is the threshold where discretionary spending explodes. You may call it a narrative but the record sales of iPhones and SUVs prove the cash is real.
A 10-year-old girl, Tanishka Sharma, died under mysterious circumstances at Presidium School, Noida. No FIR for 15 days. No CCTV for 2 months. And now the school says the cameras “weren’t working.” Something is clearly wrong.
Her mother has already lost her husband. Now she’s fighting alone to know what happened to her daughter. Justice is her right, not a favour.
I request @myogioffice, @noidapolice@Uppolice intervene. And I urge @aajtak , @republic@BBCHindi , @ABPNews to cover this case so this mother’s voice is finally heard.
For Context-
Those “smart” bhakts justifying the Tejas crash aren’t defending India - they’re defending corruption, nepotism, bribery, lying, cheating, hate, bigotry, and every other evil imaginable. They’ve traded conscience for blind loyalty.
DAY 29 😳
There is still NO action from @bihar_police .
Doesn’t look like they are concerned about the safety of children from a sexual predator roaming the streets freely. Do you have children of your own @GopalganjPolice ?
Some people have bloody audacity to compare india 🇮🇳 to china 🇨🇳, you can’t compare this country 🇮🇳 to Philippines 🇵🇭 and Bangladesh 🇧🇩 .
- A Traveler who has travelled all over world
Instead of abusing this traveler we Indians must introspect and change things in our system.
Bihar Police is threatening to arrest and jail my friend after he complained on X about their abuse and assault by police officer.
Take note, CM @NitishKumar ji, @samrat4bjp ji, @drsanjaymayukh bhaiya
Repost it for better reach so that the victim could get help and action could be taken against the corrupt & ill-mannered police officers.