@YasarARahman you guys don’t apply the same standards to everyone is the issue. the problem with people is that they find 101 excuses when their Shuyukh are caught sitting with “Ahlul Bid’ah” but automatically boot from the manhaj a shaykh they don’t like when they see him do the same thing
@Ibn_Hibban@Tarrasbulba123 the problem is that you guys don’t apply the same jarh to everyone, when it comes to your scholars that you guys like it’s all husn al dhan and he was forced but the scholars you don’t like, he’s fraternizing with ahlul bidah. stay consistent ahki.
Imām Mālik was the first to compile an authentic book of ḥadīth named al-Muwaṭṭaʾ. It contained 1,720 ḥadīths. The book was approved by 70 scholars and thus called al-Muwaṭṭaʾ.
Imām al-Shāfiʿī memorised the al-Muwaṭṭaʾ and recited it to Imām Mālik, who replied:
Imam Abū ʿAbdullāh al-Zubayri al-Shāfiʿi (d. 318 AH), in the chapter “The Refutation of Those Who Denied the Hand”, commented on Quran 38:75, saying:
❝...If it were as the Jahmiyyah claim, that it means the hand of niʿmah (blessing), then it would have been one hand. But in the speech of the Arabs, the form yadayya (my two hands) is used only for the two hands belonging to one's own essence❞
#ClassicalPureShafiiyyah
@akbereo how could they be part of ahlul sunnah if they don’t follow the sunnah, their scholars like al razi and al juywani don’t even take ahad narrations when it comes to itiqad which is like more than half of the sunnah lol.
• The Ijmāʿ on the Salafi creed, as reported by Imam Ḥarb al-Kirmāni (d. 280 AH), who was a student of Imam Aḥmad, Imam Abū Bakr al-Ḥumaydi al-Shāfiʿi, and Imam Isḥāq ibn Rāhwayh, among others. He said:
“This is the doctrine of the Imams of knowledge, the people of Athar (tradition), and Ahl al-Sunnah who are known for it and are followed in it, from the time of the companions of the Prophet ﷺ until our present day.
I have encountered those whom I encountered from the scholars of the people of Iraq, the Hijaz, the Levant, and others upon this.
Whoever opposes anything from these doctrines, criticizes them, or disparages those who hold them—then he is a dissenter, an innovator, outside the Jamāʿah, and has deviated from the methodology of the Sunnah and the path of the truth.”
@ojora@Monotheist_7 The Prophet (ﷺ) kissed one of his wives and went out to pray (salah). He did not perform ablution. 'Urwah said: I said to her: Who is she except you! Thereupon she laughed. Abi Dawud 179. Goes to show that with even kissing your wife that your wudu isn’t broken. الله اعلم
@hashimiyy_ @dr_dar this again means nothing because it still indicates that it’s more than one which kills the “metaphorical” perspective because “hand” here only meant “power,” then saying two hands becomes meaningless. Power is not counted or dual. We just negate its resemblance to creation.