Allen

Old Butthead from “Beavis and Butthead”

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

Patrick Mahomes' and Tom Brady's postseasons by year.

Mahomes has been one of the best postseason QBs we've ever seen.

Brady posting good efficiency while also having by far the largest sample size this century is also very impressive.

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@TFG_Football Absolutely

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@DMVFootballGuy @MySportsUpdate Nope, he’ll finally get to play with a real QB

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@ryanmichael True, because PFF grade vastly understates sack impact

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@TooNDaAlpha You’ve reached peak fanboy brainrot if you think Herbert’s in his own tier lmfao. Amazing QB, absolutely not in his own tier.

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@Santitos1225 @JustinHerbertLA @mibpj2 @That_Hurts Now compare the offensive supporting cast of Hurts vs Maye during that time lol.

Maye’s 2025 was already significantly better than any season of Hurts’ career — and that was with meh offensive support.

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@mibpj2 @That_Hurts I don’t know how, but I’m still shocked by how stupid most Eagles fans are. Maybe that makes me the stupid one at this point…

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@ChiefsWashed Yep, definitely deserves huge props for fixing the sack issue — didn’t think he’d be able to do that so quickly and/or to that extent. Like you said though, still a mediocre QB at this point, all things considered.

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

She managed to gather a list of garbage counting stats and advanced stats that (mostly) exclude rushing value — awesome.

Now what about stats that include all plays (aDYAR per play, EPA/play, QBR)?

Not to mention that Caleb had the good-great weapons, a great OL, and a T5 offensive mind.

The Caleb stans are lobotomites.

[Kirsten Tanis @Kirsten_Tanis1]

@FLDadReborn @Ky1eLong @BarstoolBigCat 7th in passing yards
6th in passing TDs
11th in ANY/A
7th in Pass DVOA
9th in EPA/DB
7th in pass EPA (ESPN)

But 22nd. Ok 😂

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@JigBobo EPA-based metric that actually takes all plays into account instead of needlessly axing non-scramble runs, so yes

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@UberHansen Burrow has 0 argument for QB1

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@ChiefsWashed Yeah true. Deep ball accuracy importance is probably overblown. At least relative to short-intermiedjate throws

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@mc1243657 @jacobinfante24 100%

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@TokenRandall @WiscoBarrelMan @jacobinfante24 It’d help if he was accurate enough to hit the broadside of a barn

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@TokenRandall @WiscoBarrelMan @jacobinfante24 hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaah

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@denizselman33 @PattonAnalytics All of that is inconsequential when you consider Hurts’ supporting cast was 10x better than Maye’s. Maye would have put up video game numbers with that 2022 Eagles squad — just a far better QB.

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@jekthesnekk @4WhomJBellTolls The you could prove the pope is catholic afterwards

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@johan_padmos @4WhomJBellTolls *at least*

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@PaxRomanAnthony @UberHansen https://t.co/wvMibve1wi

Here’s EPA/play excluding tush pushes. Notice anything?

[Allen @AllenBogarty]

@coopuhscoopuh @Stevenharris68 @jordancope15 Yeah I hope he's good to go.

By the way, looked into the QB sneak EPA, and like I assumed, the impact isn't very meaningful. I excluded all 0-2 yd sneaks (both from EPA earned and play count).