Kiffin has never “locked in” his whole career for any length of time. In his first 12 years as a head coach, with many good rosters, Kiffin never won 9 games in back to back seasons. Every other year he lost 5+ games.
2024 was the year that broke the streak, but he had an absolutely loaded roster and went 9-3 vs a very easy schedule losing to unranked Kentucky and Florida and missed the playoffs with a preseason favorite.
The transfer portal has helped Kiffin immensely because he doesn’t have to really plan out and build a program. But it also creates huge roster turnover and can lead to locker room issues which he was able to largely dodge due to where he was and who he played. Managing that at LSU is a different beast entirely.
Everyone forgets that Kiffin at FAU went 5-7 sandwiched between his two 10-win seasons that got him the Ole Miss job. That was fine at FAU, but do you think LSU fans will tolerate that level of inconsistency?
Love Lane looking at every angle to give LSU best chance to win.
But it’s time to close up shop on this crusade & lock in
Every moment spent on potential players rather than current players is a moment lost
Distractions have cost his teams before, don’t let it happen again.
In even years, Lane Kiffin has lost 5+ games 7 of 8 times.
I guarantee you when I tweeted this in September everyone said “surely this trend can’t continue…” Welp.
Kiffin has never “locked in” his whole career for any length of time. In his first 12 years as a head coach, with many good rosters, Kiffin never won 9 games in back to back seasons. Every other year he lost 5+ games.
2024 was the year that broke the streak, but he had an absolutely loaded roster and went 9-3 vs a very easy schedule losing to unranked Kentucky and Florida and missed the playoffs with a preseason favorite.
The transfer portal has helped Kiffin immensely because he doesn’t have to really plan out and build a program. But it also creates huge roster turnover and can lead to locker room issues which he was able to largely dodge due to where he was and who he played. Managing that at LSU is a different beast entirely.
Everyone forgets that Kiffin at FAU went 5-7 sandwiched between his two 10-win seasons that got him the Ole Miss job. That was fine at FAU, but do you think LSU fans will tolerate that level of inconsistency?
@Richard35479163 There are only 2 even years in that span.
In 2022 he went 8-5
In 2024 he went 10-3, the sole exception, but lost two unranked games with a top-5 roster in CFB and missed the playoff
Model update for this week.
LSU is still #2 after handling Auburn 38-17. The AP has them #15.
The biggest story this time of year stems from what the model can't see - like injuries. 🧵
@HYPER_GROYPER I know it was in response to that - it was just silly and untrue.
I view Tennessee’s injury situation today as similar to Alabama’s vs Tennessee.
This is the game where the starting QB is hurt for UT, not the Bama game.
@JimmyStein_LOB@duncan_byr24197@JoshPateCFB There’s plenty of room to disagree with the rankings. Lots of things to subjectively weight.
Where people absolutely lose me is with the outrage that the factors aren’t weighted exactly the way they want.
@laurenpoe I’ve done a lot of dives recently into this.
The conclusion I’m coming to is that judging SOR based on a playoff team doesn’t actually make it playoff-centric, it just biases harder for all losses to count equally.
SOR using a prefect team ends up just being fewest losses.
Why SOR doesn't work the way most think:
SOR compares your record against a hypothetical team's record with the same schedule.
Most think that mainly just weights SOS. It doesn't.
Compared to a hypothetical perfect team, it ranks purely off fewest losses.
Compared to a hypothetical worst team, it ranks purely off most wins (effectively the same thing).
The better the "hypothetical team" you compare to (like a playoff team), somewhat ironically, the more it punishes you for losing to elite teams.
Right now, in FEI, Alabama has the #1 SOR compared against the average team, and #4 compared against an elite team.
UCLA, undefeated with no top-10 FEI games played, is the opposite: #1 compared to elite, #4 vs average.
ESPN's FPI, as with most SORs, is based on a top-25 teams and tends to punish losses far more than reward good wins. That's why it has UCLA the #1 SOR (with #67 SOS) and Georgia the #2 SOR (with #22 SOS).
Also in ESPN SOR, 1-loss Boise (#79 SOS, no ranked wins) is still ahead of 3-loss SC and Wisconsin (#19/#20 SOS, multiple ranked wins).
Ultimately, because they're so heavily biased towards punishing losses, most SORs are really just a tiebreaker for teams within 0-1 L of the same record.
@thafury24@UCCowboy@JoshPateCFB No but see they want the most eyeballs possible for the playoff which is why ESPN naturally favors the SEC and not, say, the Big Ten who has larger markets and would likely drive better revenue for the playoff.
Duh.
@HunterK_Brad Ah, yeah. I do get that.
But the problem I'm discussing is that most all rating systems in CFB use a flat "rating," even though some schemes only work against bad teams, and others work the same against everyone.
Spread vs pro style offenses scale VERY differently.
One of the fundamental problems with college football advanced stats is they generally don’t have a “scaling” factor.
LSU dominates models because against most teams, they perform as well as Texas. That’s most of a flat “rating.”
But against top-30 teams, it doesn’t scale.
@HunterK_Brad While we adore FEI and cite it often, I'm not sure that it has a separate "scaling" component.
Meaning, I'm not sure that it's ratings contemplate that a team may see more or less dropoff as competition level increases.
@serenityposting These two approaches give notoriously awful final rankings. (In Colley, ND won 2012, Bama won 2016, UCF won 2017, all AFTER the postseason).
They're fun to follow, but absolutely unusable for a playoff rankings. Colley as a matter of math basically MUST rank an undefeated #1.
The biggest issue with the CFP rankings is the same reason it drives so much media discussion.
It's not a solvable problem.
Alabama is ahead of Texas and Tennessee in the BCS, with even more top-25 SEC teams (LSU is ranked).
It's all subjective, and every approach has flaws.