Founder of @CyberCapital, Europe’s Oldest Cryptocurrency Fund, full-time crypto researcher & investor since 2013. Artist. My words are not investment advice.
1/21) I used to be one of Solana's biggest critics
Covering the fake usage numbers, centralized design, downtime, lies & fraud
In this thread, we go over all my old critiques one by one & explore how SOL has changed:
Let me explain as we pivot for decentralization's sake:
@3DotWeb Long-term security budget is completely broken as a consequence of not scaling the system
That sets it up for an inevitable collapse within 6-10 years, including increasing inflation beyond 21M
The opposite of what people expect from a "Store of Value":
https://t.co/aV0FdmKpXv
WARNING: BTC is vulnerable to a bank run! ⚠️
If a panic sets in; the vast majority of 33M on-chain users will not be able to exit
The queue would in fact be 1.82 months long!
Potentially even triggering a death spiral, annihilating investors; BTC's code & math do not lie: 🧵
All of these numbers can be independently verified, by looking at the BTC source code on your own full node!
The Math: 🎓
The figure for on-chain BTC holders was taken from @glassnode's analysis on March 2023
The TPS calculation is based on Max Theoretical TPS: (Block size (1.66MB)/Transaction size (374B)) / Block time (10M) = TPS (7.75)
We use the P2PKH TX format with 2 inputs & 2 outputs, to better represent an "average user"
Even though Segwit allows for 4MB blocks this cannot all be filled with TXs, historically the largest BTC block filled with TXs was 1.66MB so we will use that number
(1740636.16/374) / 600 = 7.75 TPS (rounding down to 7 as BTC cannot execute partial TXs)
7x60 (minutes) = 420x60 (hours) = 25200x24 (Days) = 604,800x30 (Months) = 18,144,000 (Monthly TXs)
33000000 (On-chain Users) / 18,144,000 (Monthly TXs) = 1.818 (months)
The Reality: 💀
These are all extremely conservative estimates, as they assume zero network activity outside of these on-chain users exiting...
It is important to understand that the BTC network cannot actually support month-long queues, it cannot even support week-long queues
In reality, TXs would get stuck & eventually get dropped entirely (TXs drop after 3 days)
Making it entirely impossible for smaller parties to exit, as only parties paying thousands of dollars for fees will get their TXs cleared in such a scenario (fee spike), such as large custodians & banks, as the capacity is finite, no matter how much people pay
That is why self-custody over BTC is completely unsafe & we should be advising people against it!
This will also only get worse as BTC surges in popularity, as most have no idea how deeply flawed BTC really is
Death Spiral: 🌪
This type of panic would certainly also have a relationship with the price of BTC
As a price drop would lead to a drop in the hash rate, as some miners would no longer be profitable, forcing them to shut down
However, due to how the difficulty adjustment algorithm works; a 2-week readjustment period (measured in block time)
A sudden drop in hash rate can severely affect the speed & capacity of the network, if half the miners left, for instance, block time would also drop in half & the readjustment period could take up to a month!
Causing the queue to be over 3 months long, deepening the panic & causing the price to crash even more which in turn causes more miners to shut down, which would slow down the chain even more, causing the price to crash & even more miners shutting down, etc: a vicious cycle
BTC's security budget is also unsustainable & will likely run out within the decade, something I have covered in far more depth elsewhere. This means that we have a definitive timeline, as a security budget crisis is very likely to trigger the death spiral scenario I have described here, that is if it does not happen before that
L2s also offer zero solutions against this crisis from playing out, as "true BTC L2s" still require some form of interaction with the base layer in the form of an on-chain TX for self-custody
Pure Greed: 🤑
There are literally ZERO use cases that can be supported by 7 TPS, making BTC by definition purely speculative. Unable to effect any real change in the world by virtue of it literally being useless
For reference; FedWire & Chips on average do around 12 TPS (inter-bank settlement), PayPal does 200 (online payment), while VISA & Mastercard average at around 5k TPS (retail)
All while BTC's crypto competitors can exceed 10k TPS, or even 500k TPS in some cases, all without sacrificing decentralization! There is no excuse anymore for keeping the limit this low, something I have covered extensively elsewhere
Conclusion:
Mass self-custody over BTC is a lie, even worse, it is a dangerous narrative to promote! The kinder narrative would be to warn people against self-custody on BTC, at least ETH got that right within their L2 paradigm (by promoting centralized solutions)
The only way BTC can be adopted on mass is through centralized custodians & banks. So please do not pretend as if this is "freedom money". All that does is set more people up for absolute disaster when the inevitable collapse comes
To make things even more tragic, this was never the original design, intent & vision for Bitcoin, it was hijacked along the way & completely perverted from its original goals
I love Bitcoin & that is why we must speak out against the horrible monster BTC has become; the antithesis of all that Bitcoin used to stand for. As it was originally intended to be freedom money, "P2P Electronic Cash" as the Bitcoin Whitepaper so boldly stated! That is how far BTC has fallen
Everything people project onto BTC is a lie, as BTC's tech & governance do not match their claims at all
I will not tell you what alternative chains to adopt, as I am no shill, but I can with confidence warn people against BTC & if you insist on still investing in BTC do not self-custody! Personally & professionally as a crypto value investor, I would not touch BTC with a ten-foot pole, as it is clearly a toxic asset
BTC is certainly doomed to collapse, as I see no viable path for change within the necessary timelines, there is, however, still much hope left on the horizon for cryptocurrency as a whole
As Bitcoins original vision now thrives in its children instead! 🕊
SOL's path to the top is clear:
BTC is a pet rock with ZERO utility, collapsing security & no scarcity long-term
ETH's ivory tower overlords are BLIND to the needs of business & finance
SOL will overtake both: A victory only made possible thanks to the failure of BTC & ETH!
@sachinXweb3 That is the wonderful thing:
The fees that apps sponsor go straight to the underlying L1, in this case, SOL, which means part of those fees are burned!
L1 economics & Sybil protection demand that everyone has to pay for chain usage
That is the L1 value proposition guarantee!
@KaspaMobile You are still missing the demand side of the equation
Agents can only make money mining if there is huge demand for it in the first place
It does not generate demand; mining follows demand; it does not create it
Economies of scale also mean normal comps are unprofitable!
Ask your doctor about Layer 2.
Rollupizumab: a part of Ethereum, so it is safe. Trust us. 👨⚕️
Warning: side effects may include downtime, loss of funds, rewritten history, week-long withdrawals, funds moved without a signature, theft, & closure.
Layer 2. Ask who holds the keys:
Loud, confident, moving. @Justin_Bons at Breakpoint: store of value, money and an app platform, each feeding the other. The chain earning the most fees earns the most security. Solana's on that trajectory. ⚡
Freedom money 🗽
@TheDesertLynx Indeed, this video might as well show people onboarding onto the Lightning Network
It makes no difference, despite some attempting to use it as a counterargument...
Even the founder of LN said BTC has insufficient capacity to support such an L2 before moving to ETH!
@MamabearK444 We have good crypto now, but the problem is indeed that the majority of Web3 prefers to play pretend
That is what makes the entire industry look bad from the outside to some
Hopefully, we can make a difference by raising awareness of the deep flaws present in chains like BTC
This is the best video demonstration of why BTC failed to be money I've ever seen lol.
The maxis solution? Print receipts of Bitcoin.
Aka fiat.
The solution Satoshi fought to divest in the first place.
@CChiemelie92195 That was what it was meant to be & that is what the grifters say it is now
Unfortunately, it is far from the truth; as BTC cannot serve as money, it cannot even serve the masses for self-custody
The video shows how ridiculous it is; that is why the lady taps the bell at 7 TPS!
@pmbug Thank you! Decided to put my newfound video-making skills to use for crypto as well
A picture can tell a thousand words, after all, & most people do not read my long-form content to the end!
Comedy can be so powerful too
This video was heavily inspired by Wes Anderson's films!
@KaspaMobile Reminds me of this Satoshi quote:
"I'm sure that in 20 years there will either be very large transaction volume or no volume"
Guess we are going for scenario two! Wild how bitcoiners ignore their founder
That is why his quotes rarely come up, to avoid the awkward conversations