@a5eef72a@Aella_Girl@pmarca This is not an argument that “we should not use violence to stop the people trying to build it”, this is an argument that “we should only resort to violence if other, more efficient means of convincing don’t work”
@Aella_Girl@pmarca I’m not sure it’s compatible to simultaneously believe “if anyone builds it, everyone dies” and “we should not use violence to stop the people trying to build it”
@tszzl I dunno man, it seems like there was at least one contractual obligation that was so unacceptable to the federal government that they were willing to detonate a company over it
@CharlieBul58993 @Miles_Brundage The edge vs cloud deployment question practically doesn’t prevent autonomous weapon usage. If current frontier language models can play video games, they can pilot drones. There are latency and connectivity constraints, but nothing insurmountable.
@littmath Given these are, on the surface, identical to Anthropic’s redlines, it probably behooves us to understand exactly why the redlines are acceptable under OpenAI’s contract, but not Anthropic’s
@sama If the government wanted to used chatgpt to analyze lawfully collected private data of American citizens at scale, would that be allowed by your contract?
@thsottiaux It’s honestly shameful watching openai rank and file fall in line for what is absolutely contractual safety-washing. You’ve been lied to, and you will have no one’s empathy when the government uses these models in ways that are already allowed by the contract you think is “safe”.
@boazbaraktcs It will not be a comfortable update for you, but the contract, as written and posted, does not forbid the government from using your models for scaled domestic surveillance, or for usage in autonomous weapons. Your red lines are not actual lines. The contract literally allows it
@boazbaraktcs@ChrisPainterYup if the OpenAI agreement has the same red lines that DoW had with anthropic, then why did the DoW cancel their contract with Anthropic and designate them a supply chain risk, and then enter into the same contract with OpenAI?