I have some free, time-saving advice Brian! Stop performing and posting poorly done studies outside your area of expertise! You will have so much more free time. Hope thay helps!
The ICJ ruled Myanmar guilty of genocide against the Rohingya.
This is the first time the ICJ has held a state responsible for committing genocide under the Genocide Convention. Previously the ICJ ruled that genocide occurred at Srebrenica, but it did not attribute the genocidal acts to Serbia under the rules of state responsibility (it held that Serbia was responsible only for violating its obligations to prevent the genocide and to punish the perpetrators). In this case the ICJ ruled that Myanmar as a state was guilty of committing the act of genocide itself.
The vote: 9-6 on the core finding that Myanmar committed genocide (also 9-6 on the finding that Myanmar failed to prevent genocide). This is a closer vote than I was expecting. It's also an unusually close ICJ vote on the merits of these sorts of claims.
Other things of note that some were keeping an eye out for:
1) Whether the ICJ would change the "only reasonable inference" requirement in order to come to the Genocide conclusion. It didn't. The ICJ maintained its jurisprudence.
2) Whether the ICJ would re-evaluate killings in the mere service of ethnic cleansing to be sufficient for concluding genocide. Here too, it didn't. The ICJ maintained its previous "both can co-exist but mere ethnic cleansing is not genocide" approach and still found Myanmar guilty.
Why? The ICJ noted several observations that were not reasonably compatible with killings that were merely in service of ethnic cleansing. Here are the strongest ones, in my view:
1) The ICJ noted that security forces attacked Rohingya as they were fleeing toward Bangladesh, which is inconsistent with simply driving them out. If a group is fleeing and will end up away from the land you seek to ethnically cleanse anyway, why go out of your way to kill them?
2) The ICJ noted summary executions, which are also challenging to explain with mere ethnic cleansing motivations alone. If they already surrendered to you, posed no threat, and you have full control of them and the power to expel them, why execute them instead?
For those noticing a pattern, summary executions (such as when an person surrenders and they are under control, yet are executed anyway) are a generalizably strong observation to appeal to as evidence for genocide, as alternative inferences tend to have a more challenging time reasonably accommodating them (without co-existing special intent) compared to many other types of killing.
Of note, the systematic summary executions of Bosnian Muslim men and boys after the fall of Srebrenica were central to the ICJ’s conclusion in the 2007 judgment that those events constituted genocide. Here too, the summary executions of Rohingya were one of the factors that made genocidal intent viewed as the only reasonable inference.
Myanmar has been found to have committed genocide against the Rohingya by a vote of 9-6 in the ICJ. This is the first time a state has ever received such a verdict. Some interesting points about the judgement:
1. Myanmar's security forces were found to have committed 3 of the 5 acts under article II:
(a) killing members of the group - Around 10,000 Rohingya were killed in the 2017 clearance operations which included the direct targeting of civilians, stabbing of men, women and children, widespread indiscriminate shooting, and widespread burning of homes, even with whole families locked inside
(b) causing serious bodily or mental harm - e.g. through mass rapes (at least 1,800 cases), mutilation, branding and the forced expulsion of over 700,000 Rohingya to Bangladesh
(d) imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group - e.g. through state laws which restricted Rohingya marriages and births, as well as denial of birth certificates and legal recognition for Rohingya children
Despite restrictions on movement and deprivation of access to food and medical care, the court was not convinced that (c) "Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part" had been met
2. On establishing intent, 6 dissenting judges have argued that the Judgement altered and waters down the "only reasonable inference" test. The Judgement itself argues that although other intentions may have existed (namely expulsion, punishment and counter-insurgency), none of these could reasonably explain the "totality of evidence". The majority seems to have claimed that there were other reasonable inferences for *some of the evidence* but that genocidal intent is still the only reasonable inference for "all the evidence taken together".
3. A series of hateful facebook posts by the Myanmar military were not found to have been disseminated with genocidal intent, though some "sought to encourage the non-Rohingya population to engage in violence against the Rohingya as a group." Some of these posts described the Rohingya as "animals", "dogs" and "murderous rapists". Others called for non-Rohingya civilians to "sharpen their knives" or to "carry whatever you can and bravely face these animals". One claimed that India was "eliminating all the Bengalis" and that Myanmar should do the same. Another, entitled "Why did Hitler kill the Jews?" justified the Nazi murder of Polish Jews in 1939 and compared them to the Rohingya.
4. All 6 dissenting judges had "serious doubts about the considerable evidentiary weight" given to the UN fact-finding mission's reports. They seem to be suggesting that some of the reports' conclusions were ill-formed, but still accepted by the majority. It will be interesting to see how the debate over UN reports and the "only reasonable inference" test develops going forward
People in 1826: “Please invent something to stop my children dying of infectious diseases.”
People in 2026: “Have you considered that vaccines are actually the problem?”
Two centuries of progress. One spectacular failure of perspective.
I wrote a guide to clearing your nose.
I generated my advice by having subscribers use different methods so I could figure out what works and what doesn't work.
Give it a read: https://t.co/tZIDxT5jJg
Houston coach Kelvin Sampson when asked about the 59 fouls called in Tuesday’s game.
“Doesn’t matter. Talking about that is like talking about a dollar that flew out the window. Game’s over. I’m on to tomorrow, hoss.”