Hollywood storytelling has traditionally prized tonal consistency. One reason I love Korean and Hong Kong cinema is their willingness to embrace wild tonal shifts, from slapstick comedy to serious melodrama, from cutesy humor to brutal violence, sometimes within the same scene.
Is it just me that actually enjoys when a film mixes it up with tone? Feel like ‘settling on’ or ‘choosing’ a tone is a common complaint that I just think forces films into a box. I’m on board with tonal whiplash!
@MuseZack It is obviously lost on these people that one of the central themes of EAST OF EDEN is that children must find a way to free themselves from the sins, failures, and emotional burdens they inherit from their parents.
Quentin Tarantino devotes a terrific chapter to ROLLING THUNDER in his book CINEMA SPECULATION, detailing how Paul Schrader’s original screenplay was far darker and more disturbing before being significantly softened through rewrites by Heywood Gould.
John Flynn's "Rolling Thunder" (1977) is a movie of two-halves. The first part makes you believe that it is going to be a really great movie about a returning US war veteran from Vietnam. In the second half, it becomes more of a angry white guy loner revenge movie filled only with violence and blood. There was real scope in Paul Schrader's script at the start. As the movie progresses the movie's quality fades away too.
Suprisingly Kubrick was about Barcelona's biggest booster; he cast Thomas Gibson for "Eyes Wide Shut" directly from it. (As we loved Barry Lyndon & were inspired by its score for Love & Friendship.) @Criterion@bnbuzz
I was just watching clips from The Ghost and The Darkness which in the 90s was considered a second tier late summer adventure movie but now with its gorgeous location shooting, smooth camera work and confident movie star performances feels better than anything released in 2026.