Dad. Storyteller. Software guy. Gen-Xer who does have time for any of this shit because there's work to do. Also: every right-wing accusation is a confession.
To expand:
1/the law is to protect their allies but not bind them; it is to bind their enemies but not protect them
2/every conservative accusation is a confession, either in the past or future
3/bottom line: the felt experience of power, rooted in bad faith
@xmikemac@farmingandJesus Plagiarism isnβt the sin of pride?
Standing up for giving scholars their due for Godβs gift of insight IS the sin of pride?
Interesting moral calculus you got there, fella.
Allow me to retort:
(1) There's a bit of a moral gap between social media disapprobation of someone who has behaved egregiously and bashing a likely-innocent woman's head in with rocks, don't you think?
(2) Forgiveness and grace does not preclude insisting that Huff forfeit any position of leadership until he starts over from zero and takes the opportunity to learn how to behave properly.
Wes calls himself a Calvinist. But Calvin is right there in Inst. II.2.15 completely rejecting this defense.
Oh yeah. I forgot. Only nerds and Presbyterians actually give a shit what Calvin actually wrote. Other modern Calvinists have probably never cracked open this work. If they did, they'd probably call Calvin "woke" or at least a "pussy."
@noxestyle@CrowsRoots@hemantmehta Obviously, I'm a bot. I went online in 2006. I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the TannhΓ€user Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain.
@GuerillaLawyer Broadly agree. Frankly, I am surprised he got this far. Maybe there's hope for the lad after all. Maybe.
Let's see how it plays out. As for the dogpile--well that sort of thing follows a logit curve so unfortunately all you can do is sit back and wait for it to peter out.
You see, when you say this, you betray that you don't understand TST at all.
If you're a Christian who nonetheless supports religious and political freedom for all, you can think of them as constant quality assurance testing your stated commitments to such.
If you're the sort of Christian who opposes religious and political freedom--well, then, sure, go fuck yourself.
I never imagined that I would return to Christianity as an adult and yet find TST delightful and in some strange way...mostly?...on the same team as my own church, even though I continue to ask for some forbearance over our reflexive discomfort around your symbols and methods.
The story behind the name is rather macabrly comedic. A bunch of Klickitats were being held in "protective custody" at Ft. Vancouver, which was an atrociously sloppy installation even by the standards of the time. A few of them, led by Chief Umtuch, said the Sahaptian equivalent of "fuck this fucking hellhole and these white motherfuckers" and headed north.
The state militia detachment assigned to Ft. Vancouver, commanded by William Strong, intercepted Umtuch and his friends near the current townsite. A sort of "Mexican standoff" occurred, but after a heated discussion and some promises of improved conditions, Umtuch agreed to return.
After these successful nonviolent negotiations, Strong's men fired their guns into the air in celebration. Unfortunately, one of those bullets returned to earth and struck Umtuch, killing him. That was accepted as accidental and the Klickitats returned to Vancouver.
The locals originally thought an actual battle had taken place given the sounds of the gunfire. Even after they found out the truth, the area was sarcastically named "Strong's Battle Ground". Strong's name was dropped, mostly out of embarrassment.
Oh. I realized you may be a Calvinist (as Wes is). May I commend the following from the Institutes to you?
On thanksgiving for God's gift of insight: III.7.4 and III.7.6
On the rejection of the "ad maiorem Dei gloriam" defense: II.2.15
On the theft of the intellectual labor of others: II.8.45
On the coverup: II.8.47
In all these cases, direct Scriptural support is included in the text cited or in nearby sections.
---
While I'm not a Calvinist, I respect Calvin's contributions to all modern Protestant theology. You can't escape the influence of the Institutes. But if you are indeed a Calvinist, you might find them even more persuasive.
Too busy practicing their craft to notice trends in online apologetic brainrot.
But now that they know--yeah, most are pretty salty about it.
The stuff Huff ripped off is the culmination of years of difficult labor, thought, and prayer (where applicable) by other human beings, often at the expense of other important things in their lives. Proper citation is thanksgiving for their efforts.
Note this isn't about intellectual property. You don't have to ask permission to use it. You simply must recognize their long, difficult work, and disclose that another human being spent years of their lives developing those ideas.
Plagiarism denies these people human dignity and is a grave sin, in my opinion. Even the justification that one is motivated by bringing glory to God rings hollow. God gave those insights to those other scholars, not to you. If one truly walks in humility before God, what is the cost of proper citation? If anything, it reinforces one's humility and serves as a thanksgiving for God's blessing and inspiration of those scholars.
Eschewing those norms runs counter to these values, and engaging in cover-up when called to account intensifies the sin.
I don't think the risk is that AI becomes Skynet or some shit.
No, the most obvious current risk is that someone unleashes a slopstorm that triggers a polycrisis similar to the Jackpot described in William Gibson's novel The Peripheral.
That may have happened already. If so, we're going to need to do a lot of hard, unpleasant work and have a bit of luck to avoid that particular outcome.
Unlike the Y2K crisis--which indeed have been very bad if its remediation hadn't been emphasized by leaders in industry and government--I have little confidence that those in a position to call for and direct this work are either able or willing to do so. And the existential exposure we face now is orders of magnitude more dire than Y2K, as our dependence on computing is much more pervasive.
Human extinction? Not likely. But TEOTWAWKI is distressingly in play. Right now.