ابو ذر

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@AlWayluLakum @AbuUbaydahEhsan Nothing horrendous about it, it doesn’t matter if a magician is truthful or not, how can a Muslim be pleased with even the imitation of Kufr?

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@HasTa11447843 @nasafism @RaadTheShepherd You need to read the works of the ulama & not your own interpretation. Start with the sharh of ibn hajr inshallah

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@HasTa11447843 @nasafism @RaadTheShepherd There’s multiple narrations such as the narration of ibn abbas which affirms that the servants of Allah mentioned are angels.
It becomes shirk when it becomes dua, its not that hard to understand. Dua to other than Allah is shirk

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@HasTa11447843 @nasafism @RaadTheShepherd The ahadith mention Allah has servants [angels] that are present in deserted lands that can help you when lost, so seeking help from them in such scenarios would be just a normal nida, not dua. If you call out to them for other than that, this would then become Dua, thus shirk

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@RadziIqbal @D1mashqi @Jobkurdi I know they are kuffar, but if your saying theyre only kuffar for claiming the prophet ﷺ lied, then thats wrong, as they dont claim he did, if your saying there interpretation entails theyre claiming so, then many muslims fall under the same accusation

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@HasTa11447843 @nasafism @RaadTheShepherd If you read the supporting ahadith mentioned by at tabarani you will see it mentions they are are present & able

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@D1mashqi @Jobkurdi Qadianis are not kuffar?

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@HasTa11447843 @nasafism @RaadTheShepherd Firstly its a weak hadith, secondly even if we took the opinion that its meaning is sahih like Imam Ahmad, it would not be shirk, as your asking for help from those who are alive, present & able

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@itminani_ @sumudmuqawim @ZabAkbar @DrShadeeElmasry Either way his wrong, theres many buildings within Mecca that were built taller than the kaaba under the Ottoman Empire, just look at the pictures from the 1800s

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@guywithlibrary @NorbertsBurner The lughwi meaning is irrelevant to determining tawhid & shirk, according to your shari’ definition, such statements can be uttered by a heart full of imam & tawhid.
I have no issue with the Hadith you presented, I don’t see what point you’re trying to bring

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@guywithlibrary @NorbertsBurner So by your definition, it’s not shirk to ask the Statue of Liberty for help, as this nida wouldn’t fall under your definition of Duā, nor would it be shirk to direct your Duā to Buddha so long as you intend this nida to be passed on to Allah?

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@guywithlibrary @NorbertsBurner What’s your definition of a Rabb?

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@guywithlibrary @NorbertsBurner What’s your definition of Duā?

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@cherub_92 @MuhibTaqiAlDyn Look at this imbecile calling a great imam a donkey, you didn’t even realise I was quoting imam nawawi from his sharh.

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@cherub_92 @MuhibTaqiAlDyn The Abyssinian’s weren’t dancing, they were playing with their spears on a day of Eid, nothing like what the modern day sufis do, doing dhikr while banging their head believing this is some form of ibaadah

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@sumudmuqawim @ZabAkbar @DrShadeeElmasry No, if that’s what he meant then that’s different to what he said “they [the ottomans] never built a building taller than the kaaba”

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@nasafism @HarounKanj That’s not his intention

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@HarounKanj I was wondering how are you going to make this story about salafis…

[ابو ذر @drabudhar]

@KItreal512 @othmaanX Why would you expect Imam Ahmad to mention the meaning is known to a people who denied the attributes altogether?