@Lunayahrii you wrote a sentence that wasn’t a question, and it had transphobia.
Even if it WAS a question, how hard is it to go “oh, yeah, get it now.” then not keep clinging to the question needing protection, when it was a transphobic thought?
it’s not “subhuman” to be told it’s bigotry
@i_harukawa@twoboyarmyy@hugotwogo “If you explicitly do not identify as a man, why are you labeling yourself as a man”
nonbinary doesn’t mean “not a man” and “not a woman”, it’s an adjective that describes and modifies the relationship with that manhood, womanhood (and again, could be neither, or BOTH: bigender)
@i_harukawa@twoboyarmyy@hugotwogo You realize this is just regular transphobia, right?
You must conform to society in all ways, and you can’t be mad or cry wolf about it,
and it’s people being nonbinary and you just not understanding that, willfully rejecting nonbinary identities that are too complex for you.
@hlarryious@twoboyarmyy@hugotwogo If you are participating and identifying yourself by the labels provided by a society that interprets gender as functioning within a binary then you cannot be mad or cry wolf when someone rightfully expects you to fit with what the label implies
@CTinMI921@dogchasrr@markingofdesire disliking butches for being in PUBLIC spaces
bc your criteria for them being in public sapphic spaces
is they must be sexually attractive to you
IS lesbophobic
Nobody was trying to date her; yet she’s spreading otherization of butches & transmascs, and trans men before that
@Fawn_Puppy What lesbian event?
There was no lesbian event!
The person that started this is bisexual.
The event was open to the public.
Imagining it as a lesbian event doesn’t make it a lesbian event. That’s trans panic occurring…
@turningmystile People will self-insert lesbians into issues
where the event is a bi trans woman upset at seeing cis men at a bar open to the public PRIOR to a sapphic event, also open to the public, and friends of any gender can be invited.
Almost like lesbianism is a cover for tphobia/gender
@turningmystile another one, now confirmed.
& this wasn’t even a lesbian bar
Yet everyone keeps talking about it as a “lesbian event” & “think about the lesbians” and “lesbian spaces”
YET It was NOT a lesbian-ONLY event
(and it was a bi woman who led the tmasc hate to begin with, so again…!😭)
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal “we consider them cisgender again”: no, they are whatever gender they say they are
You are not the gender authority who can label everyone else, while ERASING their self-IDs
You didn’t like it when ShellTerminal mislabeled you, yet you stand around doing it to tons of trans men
@villainsenjoyer Trans men getting called “predators to sapphic spaces”
and it’s all over an invented trans panic
where 1 woman, who’s posted bigotry multiple times against all trans men, before and after, got upset at cis men existing, in an open-to-the-public bar, where she made eye contact.
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal Never said transmasculine is identical to trans man
You didn’t read the link… it highlights that being a trans man is not exclusive or dependent of being transmasculine or nonbinary
People can be both
You’re going to say E lliot Page isn’t a trans man? Because he’s also enby?
@eddyardonm@firsteyera The organizer of the event says you’re wrong, Eduardo. Maybe read the invitation before saying all that.
You can’t enter a space, open to the public, and then belatedly try to impose gender segregation, into spaces open for the public and inviting of friends.
@firsteyera What's not clicking is why you're not understanding that simply, dedicated sapphic events involve women. No one said that you inherit the social class or threat of it, as you stated. However, sapphic events where women are looking for women don't involve men.
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal You made trans men a binary term.
There’s binary trans men and nonbinary trans men. You have put “trans man” behind a binary, where it is not required to be binary.
https://t.co/jPsWBocCrf
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal@possumsauce1@n4t0rn4t0@yunatuna17 Making assumptions (which happens in society) doesn’t make those assumptions correct.
An individual is in charge of their identity. Presentation ≠ identity.
Nothing about presentation guarantees gender.
@ShellTerminal@possumsauce1@hlarryious@n4t0rn4t0@yunatuna17 Yes, not all trans men wear binders. That doesn’t change anything about my statement. If someone is wearing a binder, dressing as a man, and asking to be referred to as a man, one can assume they’re a man, yes?
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal You recognize yourself as a woman, and as “not a binary woman”
yet you’ve spent how many tweets not recognizing not-binary men as NOT men??Rather than “not a binary man” and yet still a man. Bc nonbinary people can ALSO be women and men, like you are “not a binary woman”.
🙃
@ShellTerminal@hlarryious I’m not a “trans woman” because I’m not a binary woman. I’m transfeminine, and I’m a woman, but that isn’t synonymous with “trans woman”. Vice versa for trans men.
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal Manhood is not binary.
Womanhood is not binary.
It can be binary - some people experience binary womanhood and binary manhood.
But it is not a requirement to be binary to be a man or woman. And why you keep being exorsexist, demanding that. (It’s Euro-Christian belief system)
@ShellTerminal@hlarryious You can have he/they pronouns because “he” isn’t exclusive to binary genders. But one cannot be a binary non-binary person, because these are identities that only exist and make any sense as exclusive of each other.
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal No, trans women who are in community with gay men, and see their identity as “gay man” or “f-slur”
Why would you call them lesbians when they don’t call themselves lesbians?
This is where your prescriptive assigning of other people shows up as being entirely wrong and ignorant.
@LiquidAlicorn@himsbian has there been an official description of the “harassment”?
Because I’ve seen her describe it twice as staring/“leered at by people”
she’s posted anti-all trans men posts before
and says she left when she realized it was “mostly dudes”
(sapphic event was later that night)
@ShellTerminal@patternscreamr2 We should be “emulating” allowing people to self-identify
Also, the people knew they were lesbian, transgender, and men, and still had them in the spaces. Same as lesbian, transgender, and women included
Gay trans women also exist
People can self-sort: trust their identities!
@hlarryious@ShellTerminal “Transgender butches” in the lesbian community are a phenomenon that largely exist due to historical exclusion of trans men, I really do not think we should be emulating that
@patternscreamr2@ShellTerminal “Third-sexing of transgender people”
um, you’re the only one describing third-sexing, AND you are the one not recognizing transgender people as the identities they say they are
If anyone’s 3rd-sexing here, it’s you.
While trying to forcibly shove everyone else into a 2-box binary
@MostlySoftware Wanting spaces to be inclusive of ALL who WANT to attend, and not constructed on an artificially forced binary
(at an event that is OPEN to the public, bc the organizers aren’t transphobes…)
is now “privilege”
Inclusion isn’t a seesaw! you can attend without pushing out others.
@transspiritsoul i feel like the larger issue most tgirls have been trying to get at with this is transmascs leveraging privileges they're granted by virtue of being afab in these spaces to oust trans women they find irritating or difficult to compete with