“Being in a minority, even in a minority of one, did not make you mad. There was truth and there was untruth, and if you clung to the truth even against the whole world, you were not mad.” ― George Orwell, 1984
@GoodSideSport I'm sure the Boks are pissing themselves. Who would have expected a hostile Aviva after what happened this week? It's becoming clearer why you rate yourself so highly. Amazing insight on display here. Genius.
Well, this is quite the masterpiece of selective reasoning. 😂 I must say, the confidence with which you’ve managed to misunderstand virtually every aspect of this situation is almost admirable. Almost. Let’s work through your little production, shall we? I’ll try to keep it simple.
Firstly, Rassie was responding to a question from an Irish journalist concerning Sam Prendergast’s disciplinary situation. He wasn’t wandering around making unsolicited declarations for your entertainment. I realise context can be a nuisance when you’re trying to manufacture outrage, but unfortunately, it still matters.
Secondly, your theatrical little ‘but the circumstances were different’ is particularly amusing. Different circumstances can warrant different assessments. That’s rather the point of considering context. Astonishing that something so elementary apparently requires explaining.
Thirdly, nobody is arguing that South Africans should be entitled to say absolutely anything without consequences. The issue is whether disciplinary standards are being applied consistently. I appreciate that fairness and freedom from consequences might sound interchangeable when you’re determined to misunderstand both, but I assure you they’re not.
Fourthly, your imaginary South African complaining about being ‘banned’ is another delightful invention. Questioning whether a sanction is proportionate or consistent isn’t the same as believing sanctions shouldn’t exist. One can accept accountability while scrutinising its application. Two thoughts at once. Quite ambitious, I know.
Fifthly, casually invoking Ben Smith’s name doesn’t magically transform this collection of assumptions into a coherent argument. If there’s a substantive point worth discussing, perhaps try presenting it rather than expecting everyone to be impressed by a name-drop.
And here’s the truly exquisite part: you’ve written both sides of an imaginary conversation, deliberately made one side sound ridiculous, and then congratulated yourself on your intellectual triumph. 😂
That’s a textbook straw man argument, dressed up as clever commentary.
Perhaps the next time you feel inspired to lecture an entire nation about rational discussion, you might consider actually engaging with its arguments rather than inventing more convenient ones.
Still, congratulations on winning a debate against yourself. I imagine the competition was absolutely fierce. 👏😂🇿🇦
@Slipcatch It has never been legal to influence a game of rugby union whilst off your feet. That said, @WorldRugby is (and has been for a long time) destroying the game with their ridiculous new laws. It is literally becoming touch rugby.
@StanSportRugby@WorldRugby needs to act strongly against Hansen for his disrespectful and threatening tone of voice towards all referees. Bringing the game into disrepute.
@jaredwright17@WorldRugby will ban Campese from watching rugby in his own lounge until after the next World Cup. Extremely disrespectful and threatening towards all referees.
@catourneovale Publicly asking for an opposition player’s punishment to be severe whilst disciplinary proceedings are ongoing. Nothing will happen, because he’s french 🥱
Conveniently Compiled WR Examples of Knee-Drop Tackles:
Because many (such as @CharlieFelix from Jornslism, Inc) in good faith, one believes, perused game tape and found few newly verboten tackles
thinking most instances “simultaneous,” we re-assessed WR’s examples of very bad no-no knee-drop tackles
As you’ll see from the conventional clipped compilation herewith (also freeze frames of knee before touchdown),
WR operates on a different understanding of “simultaneous” than you or I or Charlie or any sane person
Last in the attached clips is a game-tape compilation (biased, okay, but look at the tape not the captions) for comparison
Per the WR examples, I’m sure you’ll agree that any reasonable person will agree that every example in the game compilation (and many besides) fall within the ambit of WR’s idea of knee-drop tackle
Now if it were up to you or moi, none of these would be illegal
because how the hell is Lood the Jagermeister supposed to tackle comparative little people without high or kneeling, I do not know
but even the first clip in the game compilation video is not simultaneous (bizarrely, even less so) than WR’s example clips
When first I heard of knee-drop directive thought was anchored knee, waiting for runner, bollard-like
But the examples includes fractions of a second, with drop and tackle in one motion.
In editing this, swear, the interval between knee to ground is in some cases a frame or two before contact. Absolute bonkers, of course, but thems the rules.
@offtheball@bankofireland They don’t have to. Especially if you’re from the NH. No need. @WorldRugby was only joking when they implemented these new laws.