Do you need slides to explain how financial systems work?
Try these!
Covers money creation & destruction, bank payments, tiered settlement, taxation, deficit spending, gov borrowing, and savings!
https://t.co/ebPAFpjInK
1. Private bank money carries the ultimate promise to settle payments with state money. This makes private bank money a derivative of state money.
The fact that a bank can fulfill a depositor's payment instructions by transferring a deposit liability to another bank via netting or settlement in assets other than state money does not negate the underlying promise to settle at par in state money.
2. I would actually say the deposit system is a derivative bolted to THE BOTTOM of state money.
There would be no private deposit system denominated in the state’s unit of account without the state establishing that unit of account first. We could all theoretically bank, receive, and pay our state tax credits directly to the state without a private deposit system. We could not, however, get and pay our state tax credits without a state. The dependency is one-way. That is why the deposit system is the derivative layer.
The fact that banks can expand their balance sheets horizontally before seeking reserves vertically does not flip the ontological hierarchy.
3. Deposits are only “every bit as good” as central bank money if they're insured by the state. You might be fine with uninsured deposits, most are not.
The fact that the insurance payout does not pay in state money but in another deposit with the same promise is not evidence that deposits are every bit as good as state money. The existence of the insurance, however, is evidence that private bank money is not “every bit as good as” state money.
4. This is NOT to say that private bank deposits are claims on the state. They are, however, “claims on state money” in the same sense that my ticket, bought from a third-party vendor, gives me a claim to a seat in the football stadium.
If I told you that I have a seat for a Sunday night game you would correct me and say: “No, all you have is a promise by the third party vendor to a seat at the game. The stadium has no obligation to you.” You would be technically correct, but few would want to be your friend. 🙂
Then you would go on to say: “But, your third party ticket is every bit as good as a ticket directly bought from the stadium”. You’d be incorrect and have even fewer friends, because now you're inconsistent too.
Just as mainstream economists struggle to grasp that IORB makes sovereign bond issuance operationally redundant for rate control, they struggle to grasp that an employed buffer stock replaces an unemployed buffer stock as a price anchor. Both shifts require abandoning indirect…
@MarcGoldwein Mate you are complaining about risk free payments to millionaires but adhere to an economic ideology with positive government interest rates for a floating sovereign currency?
Once deployed, they technically have unlimited range over larger time horizons, can reposition at night undetected by traditional warning systems, like insects carpeting a geographic space.
What is air or space superiority in such context when Amazon delivers the ordinance.
Horrors of drone warfare:
Recharged with sunlight and prepositioned before a conflict begins, they can lie in wait.
A state may not realize it's territory has been saturated with mobile weapon systems, distributed by its own civil logistics, that persist for months or years.
Just another reason the Fed ledger should be open to the public.
All people should have a right to make purchases. Access and use should be guaranteed under the 1A.
Give people accounts at the Fed. Banks need competition.
@RedMMT Fedwire, the Fed’s gross settlement system for reserves, processes about 217 million transfers a year. The U.S. economy makes over 236 billion card, ACH and check payments a year. That’s roughly 1,000 deposit payments for every reserve transfer. ONE THOUSAND TO ONE.
@cullenroche@RedMMT Banks are 'state franchises'.
The choice of gov to permit private ownership does not invalidate the sovereign origin of the bank charter.
@GuardianGolem@LPNational Commercial Banks constantly create new money every day when they issue loans.
Can you classify which of these new deposits created by banks are 'excess'?
@LynAldenContact@ProfSteveKeen Again, causality is important here.
The CB doesn't lead the system, it follows private banks. So saying that private banks lever something that follows their actions is logically inconsistent.
You can say they 'lever equity', but bank equity is not reserve dependent.
@ProfSteveKeen@TyKeynes@tonywestonuk@GDPDynamics If you want to haul passengers and perform proper logistics, you will need more than a large kite, correct.
But I still like and recommend the software, and I hope it's development continues.
*In this case*, we can avoid miscommunication between Richard & you by showing accts.