@n0n0tagain I think it's reasonable for a school to supply some pens etc but obviously there's a limit. Asking parents to contribute would help but there'll always be some (a lot?) who don't.
Not only is this very sad, but it's also a good indication of where our education system is going wrong: focusing on the things that don't matter, neglecting the things that do.
If we cannot *expect* pupils to look after their equipment, then how on earth are we going to expect them to grapple with Shakespeare’s plays & Darwin’s theories? 2/
@Mr_Raichura@ukneighbour I'm sure a lot of children respond positively, but I've seen children turned off education as a result of what they see as disproportionate sanctions for minor offences.
@n0n0tagain I'm sure that is frustrating (although I'm not entirely sure why you aimed that at me), but maybe accepting that parents should have a voice in how their children are treated would help.
Or here's the thing, stop depriving them of their agency & autonomy, provide meaningful choice, respect their freedom & dignity and see the magic happen.
The vast majority of the problem related to behavior is caused by the stifling school environment.
Just observe those same children when they are doing something thay they are actually interested in, they behave like a completely different person.
Most of the behaviors displayed in school are because of disengagement, adults would run riots if treated like that.
Teacher spends two days as a student and is shocked at what she learned-
https://t.co/6T1WuXgf8m
The key crisis in education is that 40% of students fail to achieve a pass grade in GCSE Mathematics and English at 16 and most who fail at 16 never pass resits at 17 and 18.
@ukneighbour@Mr_Raichura Contentious as in its effectiveness is disputed, not as in some people don't like it. There's not always a match between the point of a detention and its effect, either. If it's seen as disproportionate it can breed resentment, which can lead to defiance rather than conformity.
@lmcwitch@RemoveTheRoom I'm sure some parents are vexatious, but schools also need to realise that parents have a stake in what happens to their children, and their views shouldn't be dismissed just because they're not teachers.
@ukneighbour@Mr_Raichura Important to point out it's a theory, not a law, and a contentious one at that. Agree about consistency & boundaries, but kids also often like punishments to be proportionate. Is detention for forgetting a ruler a proportionate response?
Regarding @Mr_Raichura’s post: Understanding Shakespeare or Darwin has little to do with remembering a pencil. Gifted children can struggle with executive function. Why punish rather than support? High expectations don’t require detention.
@rochdalescouser@nsdmorrison Being a respected teacher doesn't make someone's methods beyond criticism. Nor does not being a teacher invalidate an argument. The question isn't whether Raichura is a good teacher, but whether detention for forgetting a pencil actually teaches responsibility.
@nsdmorrison Some of my most brilliant university lecturers had PhDs, published research and offices resembling archaeological digs! 😂 Being organised and being intellectually capable are two very different things. Imagine judging their academic ability by whether they remembered a pencil.
@Nito_Onna_Helen@nsdmorrison Exactly. A child can understand Shakespeare, excel at science and still forget a pencil. Organisation and academic ability aren't the same thing. Teaching responsibility matters, but why assume punishment is more effective than support?
@nsdmorrison I am 52 and still 'can't look after my equipment'. Done remarkably well for myself considering this failure, love Shakespeare and geek out on scientific research. Imagine what I could have achieved if I had learned to keep hold of my ruler at school..? 🙄🤓
@rochdalescouser And it's interesting that in a thread arguing teachers shouldn't lower their expectations because of a child's disability or disadvantage, he seems to suggest that it's ok to lower those expectations if the child forgets a ruler. Is there a contradiction there?
@rochdalescouser I wonder if you also dismiss the views of non-teachers when you happen to agree with them, or is it only when they say something you don't like that not being a teacher becomes an issue?