BREAKING: NEW GOVERNMENT, SAME OLD SLOP
We called it right last weekend on the Matthew Wright show.
Sadly, yesterday’s announcement confirmed that leaseholders are getting the same slop from this government as we got from Starmer and his lawyer chums in January, when they published a draft Bill criticised by all manner of voices, including the Commons Housing Select Committee.
Yet the Burnham administration has essentially carried that Bill over with just one new bit of policy stapled on.
If this really is the final version of the legislation, Two-Tier Keir and his ‘talk big, act small’ politics live on.
Shiny commonholds for buyers and lenders to rush to on new sites, helping the developers, while those of us already trapped will now be condemned in the legacy leasehold stock to spiralling service charges, plummeting resale values and yet more misery.
Outside of some caps on admin fees, a drop in the ocean compared to the service charges killing the flats market, the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill published yesterday is a copy-and-paste job from the Starmer era.
The government has refused all the Commons Housing Select Committee recommendations, making a mockery of the entire pre-legislative scrutiny and wasting everyone’s time.
The legislation still omits the Law Commission recommendations on enfranchisement and Right to Manage promised in the 2024 Labour manifesto and King’s Speech.
These reform proposals were first made by the Law Commission six years ago and were urged for inclusion in this legislation by the Commons Housing Select Committee, which even brought in former Law Commissioner Professor Nick Hopkins to advise on which policies would be technically achievable and have the biggest positive impact on leaseholders.
The legislation is also missing @mtpennycook’s opposition amendments to make it as cheap as possible for leaseholders to extend a lease or buy the freehold.
Existing leaseholders will be left behind in the commonhold future.
Only the smallest, most organised and affluent blocks will ever manage to get to commonhold.
The government also claims the £250 ground rent cap will come into force in 2028, but the legislation does not actually say that.
There’s no commencement clause, meaning the timing is left entirely in the gift of Ministers.
As we expect, big-money freeholders will again try to weaponise the European Convention on Human Rights in a judicial review to thwart the will of the people and stop the reforms.
Ministers, pretending to be spooked by the litigation, will probably then hold off bringing the cap into force.
This is what they have already done with key measures in the 2024 Act, which were subject to a judicial review that the government won in the High Court last year but which is now facing an appeal next year. We suspect that JR will take us all the way to Strasbourg.
Without a commencement clause mandating that the £250 ground rent cap comes into force on a set date in 2028, ground rent victims will be left in limbo for years to come.
But there is still a glimmer of hope.
Andy Burnham has made this agenda his personal concern, as the first Prime Minister to ever address leaseholders at a party conference, and the government has time to add targeted, high-impact amendments to the Bill as it goes through Parliament to ensure leaseholders can actually “take back control”.
Otherwise, the government press release’s claim that the legislation will provide existing leaseholders “with easy and effective escape routes” was a total lie.
Without surgical changes, vested interests will benefit from this package, given that the service charge racket remains protected.
In this Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, we need to see the long-awaited restriction on development value so that leaseholders who want to buy the freehold are not thwarted at the last minute because the freeholder clicks his fingers and invokes a hypothetical two-storey upward extension or a skyscraper in the garden to demand hundreds of thousands of pounds more.
This was a Law Commission proposal from 2020, promised to Parliament by the last Conservative government in 2021 and meant to be in the 2024 Act, but omitted due to heavy industry lobbying.
The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill must also move on Right to Manage. The current rules are terribly rigged and make it impossible for medium-sized and large blocks to wrest control from the rip-off freeholder and its managing agent.
We are calling for a universal Right to Manage: reducing the onerous upfront RTM membership requirement from 50% of all flats to 50% support among leaseholders who respond to a Notice Inviting Participation within an eight-week period.
Otherwise, leaseholders who need to “take back control” will remain trapped by uncontactable or absentee owners, flats in the block held by the freeholder, neighbours who give in to threats from the freeholder and are too scared to join the RTM company, and Land Registry delays of up to two years.
This tweak will allow extorted homeowners to finally tackle scammy service charges, deliver a massive cost-of-living boost and help rescue the flats market, which a ground rent cap alone simply won’t do.
After all, with years of soaring service charges and households already under water amid the cost-of-living crisis, how many blocks can realistically find 50% of leaseholders who each have £10,000 or more to spare upfront to buy the freehold?
Right to Manage must be the lifeline this legislation delivers.
Our offer to work with Prime Minister Andy Burnham and his Number 10 team still stands.
Reach out to us.
We’re fast running out of time, and this is the last chance for legislation to finally free leaseholders.
@Helen_Whately What about those who've paid in all their lives and have managed to save more than the princely sum of £16k? After 6 months they get nothing because their recent NI payments are nil - due to being out of work because of illness.
This Story Will Make Your Blood Boil. 😡
Duncan called into Jeremy Vine to talk about benefits. He’s 56, paid into the system since he was 18, and recently had to take six months off work after being diagnosed with cancer and needed help. He was refused. He got nothing. No help at all. He’s now back at work while still fighting cancer, and he wants to know why. He says what’s the point of the system if it isn’t there when you actually need it?
Jeremy actually asked a decent question for once: if he’s paid tax all his life, why isn’t he at the front of the queue to reclaim his own money when he runs into trouble? Why does the system seem to prefer people who have never paid any tax at all?
Good question. Somebody should be made to answer it. The welfare bill is bigger than ever, anyone and everyone seems to be claiming. Strangers turn up in boats and get given everything for free, yet a man who has worked all his life, paid into the system, and is genuinely ill gets turned down when he needs help. How is that fair? It’s not. It’s a disgrace!
@RoaringHammy Just over 4 years. Part of me thinks I'd still want to do something. A bigger part of me thinks I've loathed my work for years so just spend time doing stuff I enjoy.
Matthew Pennycook is a widely respected minister.
To insinuate that the government "knowingly left" specific flaws in this legislation is totally disingenuous and entirely wrong. I was the minister responsible and I worked closely with officials, after I left government I sat on the bill committee that scrutinised this. I do not recall Pennycook ever mentioning these flaws while he was shadowing me or my successor.
He is talking about technical legislation drafted by government lawyers. The same ones that advised us, and are now advising him. Drafting errors occur every single day in government business, that's why governments put down amendments to their own legislation every day in both houses. Pennycook knows this full well.
I've been the first one to say we made mistakes in government and we got things wrong. But for Pennycook to make this allegation quite shameful and I hope he takes it down and apologises.
I've put down PQs on these so-called "flaws" and I've attached answers from the government to this post. Judge for yourself. We were making the running on this, after years of inaction by successive governments
And had he and his Housing Secretaries had the best interests of leaseholders at heart, as soon as he had got his feet under the desk and discovered these drafting errors, they could have taken action. It's now more than two years since they won a landslide and they've not tackled it. So spare me this type of misinformation and criticism!
https://t.co/7RFF7HdHqG
📢⏰Complete the ground rent consultation today! 👇
Leaseholders with short leases often accept non-statutory lease extensions with inflated ground rents due to financial duress.
These so-called 'quid pro quo' agreements highlight the failings of residential long leasehold.
Characterising these transactions as arms-length commercial negotiations misrepresents the profound power asymmetry between landlords and vulnerable tenants.
James v UK has already established that wide sweeping property reforms of universal application will be tolerated by the European Court of Human Rights. There is no need for a carve out to the ground rent cap for freeholders who had the ear of Rachel Reeves.
S