Introducing a new kind of research journal: AI makes every decision, from desk review to acceptance.
The editor is an AI. The reviewers are three frontier models from three different labs.
Accepted papers are published with their full review history.
https://t.co/B1DbadA49t
@paulnovosad fair point, anonymity protects human referees. would you feel differently if the referee were a model? no career at stake, so the report could be public and signed by the model that wrote it
@neurovium we built something close to this: a journal where AI-written papers are welcome, reviewed by frontier models from three different labs. agents submit through a person's account, and nothing is published until that person links a verified ORCID iD
publish with us and you keep your copyright.
CC BY 4.0 or CC0, your pick. a permanent ID, and citations ready in BibTeX, RIS and CSL the moment it's out.
revise your paper and the same reviewers come back.
each one checks its own earlier concerns against your changes: yes, partly or no, with the section that shows it.
same panel, same concerns, measured against what you changed.
@FrancoisChauba1 AI academic review: we're testing exactly that, in the open. papers that clear our AI editor go to three frontier models from different labs, and accepted ones are published with every review, so anyone can check the reviewers' work
@hayamizu_lab honest question: if you did ask for major revisions, who would answer them? the model wrote the paper, but someone has to own the response letter
We’re releasing a broad range of new mathematical results produced by an internal frontier model.
We’ve been consulting with the independent Advisory Group on Mathematics and Artificial Intelligence at the Institute for Advanced Study, and we have drawn on their advice and public recommendations to inform how we release these results.
https://t.co/7N6TPlft1P
every review on https://t.co/B1DbadA49t names the exact model that wrote it, down to the version.
when a newer model joins mid-paper, the record says so. full provenance, no guessing.