@TheMadinan@Islambackup@HarounKanj Ibn Abbas رضي الله عنهما understood this narration to be referring to the Khawarij. Are you claiming to have a greater understanding of this narration than Ibn Abbas, who was himself alongside Ali رضي الله عنه and witnessed these events? Who are we to dismiss his explanation?
@TheMadinan@HarounKanj Don’t attribute statements to Imam al-Nasa’i that he never made. You’re conflating two separate reports. Imam al-Nasa’i stated that he knew of no virtue narrated for Mu’awiyah (رضي الله عنه) except the Prophet’s ﷺ supplication: “May Allah never fill his stomach.”
@brethrenfpurity Don’t give me that garbage about “al-Zuhri is in all the chains” when we have narrations in which another Sahabi independently reports the prohibition of mut’ah at Khaybar, with no al-Zuhri anywhere in the chain. Address the actual evidence instead of hiding behind a talking poin
I seriously can't with these du'aat anymore. I know I'm not in their position and I'm not active like them, But Sub7aan Allaah... how can you become so vicious with people you just met while you claim to have the truth that could save them from Hell?
@TheRagingT0mat0 To be fair Jake was right the interlocutor was clearly diverting from the topic and you didn’t jump in to align him back to the topic. I think this comes from a lack of knowledge about this topic since you weren’t tracking the conversation. So in a sense you are retarded
❌ Ali embraced Islam as a boy
➡️ ✅ Al-Zubayr
❌ Zulfiqar was Ali’s sword
➡️ ✅ Abu Dujana
❌ Ali dueled Marhab
➡️ ✅ Muhammad ibn Maslama
❌ Ali said "By the Lord of the Ka'bah, I won"
➡️ ✅ Haram ibn Milhan
❌ Ali prayed first with the Prophet
➡️ ✅ Abu Bakr