I believe the @nvidia board is not acting in the best interest of shareholders nor in a manner consistent with their fiduciary duties.
What we know is that the board fired Jensen or forced his resignation for violating company policy and/or in response to the accusation of an affair with a spy.
They did so without careful consideration of the impact on the company, its customers, its shareholders or other stakeholders.
They rushed to judgment without the benefit of careful due diligence or even with a basic understanding of the facts.
How do we know this?
We know this by how quickly Jensen was fired and how little was known at the time of his firing.
It takes time to convene a board meeting. There was time, maybe, for one Zoom.
And this is a decision that should have been made by a board sitting in person and carefully deliberating the facts once they are known.
And they should have slept on the decision and met again the day after to discuss the facts, the risks and the other implications of their decision.
The timing and lack of information did not allow for careful board deliberation.
While boards can fire a CEO for an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate, it should not be an automatic decision. That is why we have boards comprised of humans and not agents.
A board should consider whether or not such a relationship was consensual or whether it was an abuse of power dynamics. And a board has to consider what the impact of the firing is on all stakeholders.
If I were in this board, I would not have rushed to judgment based on articles in the media. I would have made sure the board had all of the facts so it could make a careful and informed decision.
Boards of Delaware companies have a duty of care which means they must make informed, prudent and good faith decisions. This clearly did not happen here.
What law firm is advising this board?
Or is the board even taken good legal advice?
It doesn’t look like it.
And now the board is compounding its failures by insisting that there is no possibility for Jensen’s return as CEO.
Why is it in the best interest of the company to foreclose the possibility of Jensen’s return and to do so before all of the facts are known? This is yet another breach of their duty of care.
Furthermore, the board has launched an investigation whose scope is unknown. Investigations can be extremely damaging to a company and should be carefully targeted to address whatever facts need to be known rather than be overly broad in scope.
In short, this looks like a series of major governance failures by directors that panicked due to headlines in the media. They likely felt compelled to do something because they were afraid of looking bad in the media, not because it was the right thing for them company.
They couldn’t stand the heat.
The board’s conduct here is shocking for a company of this scale and importance to our country and the world at large, particularly at this moment in history.
@unusual_whales Actions by the board seem to be a bit rushed in my opinion. I would I have pushed for suspension to let a full investigation play out. While still immoral, some reports are coming in that Alice Huang might not actually be a Chinese intelligence asset.
@StonkChris Panic selling. Letting the base build and the dust settle and then buying into some of these strong companies that have been beat up that have long term potential
@adamkapit@KobeissiLetter lol. Wild take. Not much to support that thesis.
Look at the balance sheet. The free cash flow. The operating margin is improving. Low capex. High growth.
Well ServiceNow… $NOW
You’d think they’d just informed everyone they’re going back to the stone age of no internet!
Down 20% after hours on the back of these earnings… TWENTY!
The valuation is rich but they’re still a company growing revenues at 21%, very harsh reaction in my opinion.
Seeing a drop like that is enough to get any shareholders heart pumping and head sweating.
Thankfully, the CEO Bill has just delivered an outstanding earnings call to reassure everyone the trajectory this company is on.
Subscription growth, FCF growth, the backlog and AI specific growth are all very good. Margins need watching, as do the performances of the acquisitions but this is nothing to be concerned about at this stage imo.
This is a growth company that will have various levels of growth over the next five years. I expect they will deliver some pleasant surprises along the way.
I continue to hold and if we’re lucky enough to see $100 again over the coming months, will add heavily again.