2026 economic sciences laureates Robert E. Hall’s and Michael Woodford’s research has made us better equipped to manage economic downturns.
They laid the foundation of the New Keynesian paradigm, in which models are built upon microfoundations, which means from the bottom up. Economic outcomes are the result of millions of decisions made at the microlevel by households and businesses. Using models based upon this approach, rather than simply studying the economy from a macro perspective, like a bird’s eye view, Hall’s and Woodford’s research has generated a paradigm shift in the theory of stabilisation policy.
#NobelPrize
A quick reaction. Both well deserving of the prize. Research styles could not be more different. Woodford is a cathedral builder, building stone by stone. His main book is an encyclopedia. Hall is an intellectual butterfly, looking for new angles. His main contribution is a superb insight, which changed the way we think about consumption. It takes both to make a field advance. Congratulations.
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#NobelPrize
N-Gen Fellows Presented Their Policy Briefs on Completion of Their Fellowship
Mehwish Imran presented on electricity subsidies and their fiscal impact, and @Economist_CAI presented on the GEM Board's potential to raise long-term capital for relatively small businesses.
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2025 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Joel Mokyr, Philippe Aghion and Peter Howitt “for having explained innovation-driven economic growth” with one half to Mokyr “for having identified the prerequisites for sustained growth through technological progress” and the other half jointly to Aghion and Howitt “for the theory of sustained growth through creative destruction.”
#NobelPrize
A snapshot of our totally failed governance:
2 crore 60 lakh kids out of school. The highest in the world. More than India and China, which have 5 times our population.
78% of 10-year olds cannot read two sentences properly.
40 % kids are mentally and physically stunted.
2nd highest neo-natal mortality in the world, equal to South Sudan.
The highest population growth rate in Asia outside of Afghanistan and equal to the worst in Africa.
10 crore 50 lakh (40%) Pakistanis living under poverty according to the World Bank
Government schools not being able to teach adequately anywhere with Sindh��s school worst in the nation.
No water in much of Karachi for years now. No collection of garbage. Roads marked with potholes. Basic civic facilities remain a distant dream.
No breathable air in Lahore for 3 months every year. Citizens of Lahore lose about 5 years of their life expectancy due to this air pollution. This is now expanding to other cities of Punjab and KP.
Crime worsening across Pakistan. Police largely either ineffective or corrupt.
And yet:
We have the highest rates of electricity and gas not just in South Asia but across richer gas-importing countries such as South Africa, Thailand, etc.
We have some of the highest income tax and sales tax rates in the world, with tax on salaried individuals of 38.5%, on business individuals of 49.5, and on companies of 59%.
We have sales tax of 18% on most everything you buy so that poor end up paying a larger fraction of their incomes in sales tax than the rich.
We still have large federal deficits that increase our debt and mortgage our future.
We have public sector companies losing about Rs 700 billion annually.
Our economic growth remains so low that we aren’t able to absorb all the people entering the labour market every year, thus increasing unemployment and despondency. And faster growth only leads to inflation and devaluation.
On the other hand:
PPP has been in power in Sindh for 16 consecutive years. PMLN has been in power for 12.5 of the last 16 years in Punjab. PTI has been in power for 11 of the last 16 years. What have these parties achieved in their provinces even when flushed with cash from your taxes?
These three parties have also shared power in the federal government during the last 16 years. What have they got to show for it?
And still:
We sit today with total breakdown of our politics. Our capital is closed today, as it was yesterday. Intercity travel in Punjab has become impossible. Flights from Islamabad airport are being cancelled.
But even when things become normal again, politics will still be broken. Completely broken. Politics is now only for achieving and maintaining power. Not for public service. There are no moral redlines left in politics. Stealing elections is not dishonourable anymore. Financial corruption is being normalised across all three parties.
Yet we are not willing to admit that our governance has failed our people completely and we need a new governance model.
Please remember: Nothing we can do and no party in power will succeed, unless we change our governance model.
Failure of PIA’s Privatisation
The Shahbaz Sharif government’s failure to privatise PIA has to be understood in its proper context.
First of all, PIA is set to lose over Rs 150 billion ($550 million) in the last quarter of this year and the next year. These further losses will now be borne solely by the people of Pakistan.
PIA had a total debt of over Rs 800 billion ($2.9 billion) and of this the government was absorbing over Rs 600 billion ($2.16 billion) but passing on over Rs 200 billion ($ 720 million) in debt to the private sector bidder for it to pay.
PIA’s losses, visible and not-so-visible, are increasing exponentially. The privatisation process should have considered that by selling PIA it was not only stemming future losses but also opening up the Pakistan aviation sector. This would have created a lot more jobs and provided competitive air travel services to Pakistanis around the world.
The government initially was insisting on retaining 40% shares of PIA and also asking that the private sector bidder inject all 100% of the money required for PIA operations and expansion but that the government shareholding not be diluted. This requirement was mind boggling, to say the least. Even in the end it never agreed to a simple dilution of the government stake if it chose not to invest more.
Initially there were four very serious and credible parties interested in bidding. Younus Brothers consortium had lined up the Turkish carrier Pegasus (which has 110 aircraft in its fleet) as the operator. Fly Jinnah had Air Arabia (which has 77 aircraft in its fleet) as a partner in its bid. Pak Ethanol consortium had lined up a Swiss company as its expert aviation partner. There was also the Arif Habib consortium, which was also backed by aviation experts and big Pakistani businesses. All four of them, plus some others, walked away from the bidding. Why?
It suggests that either the government was never interested in selling PIA or it thought it was too clever and will be able to get the private bidders to pay more for less. In the end, all credible bidders walked away.
The decision to have the bidders submit bid bonds two days before final submission was also another strategic error, as it told the eventual bidder that it was the only bidder. Such basic mistakes speak very little of the competence and forethought behind the process.
Where do we go from here. I would suggest that SIFC, whose job it is to facilitate investment and support the government, to call all the bidders who walked away and ask them why they walked away and what facilities and concessions do they need. Second, SIFC should also call the people responsible for this fiasco to explain why did they come up with difficult and unreasonable conditions so that all serious bidders walked away. They should also be asked who will pay PIA the additional Rs 200 billion ($720 million) that PIA is bound to lose over the next 15 months.
Finally there should be a committee of eminent professionals from amongst people like Salim Raza (ex SBP Gov), Zakir Mehmood (ex HBL President), Aftab Manzoor (ex MCB President), Zafar A Khan (ex Engro CEO and Chairman PIA), Syed Yawer Ali (Chairman Nestle Pak), and Farrukh Khan (ex MD, PSX) who should be entrusted with negotiating with any of the above bidders or another party and selling PIA with legislation to give it legal cover and protection from NAB.
Impact of IPPs, Capacity Payments & Rising Electricity Bills I Forensic ... https://t.co/EDr5UEeqMK via @YouTube.
Understand the power sector. Subscribe to haque economics. On YouTube.
You have been great motivation and encouragement for us!
Your absence will leave a significant void in @PIDEpk. Your leadership and mentorship will be greatly missed.
@nadeemhaque wishing you a healthy and happy life ahead ♥️
Honoring Dr. Nadeem ul Haque: A Visionary Leader & Mentor
As Dr. Nadeem ul Haque concludes his transformative five-year tenure at PIDE, his visionary leadership has profoundly shaped the institution. Under his guidance, PIDE became a hub of innovation, driving forward fresh perspectives on economic development, urban planning, and market-driven reforms, to name just a few. His global networks connected PIDE with leading thinkers worldwide, extending its influence well beyond Pakistan.
Minister of Planning, Ahsan Iqbal, also acknowledged Dr. Haque’s legacy, recognizing his pivotal role in shaping the future of economic discourse and development in the country.
In honoring his achievements, Ahsan Iqbal urged the PIDE staff to continue Dr. Haque’s vision, emphasizing that the best way to honor his service is to carry forward his work for the betterment of the institution and the nation.
Dr. Haque's legacy as a mentor—more than just a leader—is perhaps his most enduring contribution. He nurtured talent, fostered collaboration, and created an environment where innovation flourished. As he moves on, his vision and wisdom will continue to inspire PIDE’s journey forward.
Insights from research help in strategic distribution of resources and effective policy making that can stimulate growth or tackle urgent social challenges. Join via Zoom,
Meeting ID: 98630231695
Passcode: 381153
#PIDE2024#PakistanEconomy#ResearchInsights#PolicyDebate
PIDE Conference Alert!
"Insights from Research on Pakistan's Economy"
Join us LIVE on October 7th, 2024, from 9 am-5 pm at Main Hall, Roomy Signature Hotel, Islamabad!
In line with our tradition of fostering rigorous research and policy discourse, this conference will serve as a unique platform to discuss and reimagine key areas of Pakistan’s economy. The event will feature presentations on some of the most critical topics researched at PIDE, including economic stability, social infrastructure, and trade and resource management. These discussions will be enriched by the active participation of expert discussants and an engaged audience.
Attend in-person or virtually via:
Zoom Link: https://t.co/yhclJj0F32
Meeting ID: 98630231695
Passcode: 381153
Livestream on Facebook: https://t.co/K1fHskCRIJ
Today, we unite to honor and extend our profound gratitude to Dr. Nadeem Ul Haque for his visionary leadership at PIDE. His unwavering commitment to groundbreaking research and transformative policy reform has set a new course for Pakistan's future. #5YearsOfPIDE
Dear Ms. Bennett,
I just read your column in @guardian about Pakistan's most loved politician/leader @ImranKhanPTI who also happens to be the founding Chairman of Pakistan's largest political party @PTIofficial .
Please allow me to respond to some of the points you have raised in your column, but before I do, may I please say that you have conveniently ignored to write about the illegal incarceration of Mr. Khan. He is languishing in jail under bogus cases since more than a year. Perhaps you ignored to write about it because you know very well that United Nations' Working Group conducted its investigation and said:
“UN working group concludes that Imran Khan's detention had no legal basis and appears to have been intended to disqualify him from running for political office”
Here are some links for your quick reference:
UN Report: https://t.co/EThnRSmhEw
News coverage of the report:
https://t.co/lzqZM9ekJQ
https://t.co/GQEOrKeD0l
Now that we have established that you ignored to mention such an important point, let's talk about your claims in the article:
Salman Rushdie:
You seem to be unaware that not just Mr. Khan, but almost entire Muslim community across the globe would refuse to share the stage with Mr. Rushdie due to his awful views about the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Secondly, you have not mentioned that when Mr. Rushdie was violently attacked, Mr. Khan said in August 2022 that:
"he understands anger The Satanic Verses created ‘but you can’t justify what happened’
Incidentally, the news was published in The Guardian:
https://t.co/zkVpn9os85
Taliban / O*ama Bin L*den:
You have mentioned about Mr. Khan calling Laden a martyr. It was a slip of tongue and it was clarified in the Parliament in 2021. Here is the link:
https://t.co/eeFaNPBJOi
Mr. Laden was an asset of US/UK/Europe when he was fighting against the Russians. In fact CIA trained him and his associates. He was labelled a terrorist ofcourse, when he turned his guns towards the West. A worth reading piece:
https://t.co/1J5hyQUCEL
You have also conveniently ignored to mention that Imran Khan's government helped evacuate over 10,000 people from Afghanistan including diplomats, staff of diplomatic missions and international agencies and journalists, when Taliban took over Afghanistan in August 2021. Links for your quick reference:
https://t.co/DGIuZFV5su
https://t.co/RuvLijry6Q
China:
Again, you seem to be unaware that Pakistan and China are decades old regional strategic allies, and China has always helped Pakistan during difficult times, when the UK and US looked away. Yes, China has major human rights issues, perhaps this is why, the UK's bilateral trade with China is valued at £86 billion?
https://t.co/PWDPxPVtuo
Comments about Women:
Give me a break! This comment, taken out of context, has been clarified several times, but here is one of the articles, incidentally published in The Guardian:
https://t.co/BLgN6EnJIo
He compared western society with what we have here in Pakistan. There is a vast difference between these societies, and people in this part of the world are not used to the freedoms that come naturally to the western world. What he said is that while strict and stringent laws should be promulgated to deal with heinous acts like rape, it may also be worthwhile to look at why there was a mention of observing purdah in Islam and whether that can help in the avoidance of rape crimes through these evolutionary times.
It is to the credit of Imran Khan’s government that a series of groundbreaking laws have been enacted in quick sequence by parliament for safeguarding human rights, the rights of women, and minorities.
I hope this post satisfies your concerns, but if not, I am happy to have a conversation, if you like of course.
In the second photo attached, are the screenshots of my email to Oxford University, detailing some of the the reasons why he is an excellent candidate for the Chancellor of @UniofOxford and just some of his achievements.
Ms Bennett is not on X. I really hope The Guardian will pick up this post and share with Ms Bennett.
Thank you.
1/2
#AbbaForChancellor
#PakistanUnderFascism