@buzzsprout Love the new MCP feature but I'm wondering if you can make it model-agnostic—it's currently limited to ChatGPT and Claude. I use @antigravity and would love to connect it to your MCP server. Thanks!
It is critically important that everyone thinking about AI become familiar with the term “handoverism.”
Many in the AI community believe that humanity should—or inevitably will—hand control of the world over to AI itself. Some view this not as a risk to be avoided, but as an outcome to be welcomed. Are we actually designing toward this future?
This worldview is particularly relevant at Anthropic. Co-founder Tom Brown said: “There’s going to be a handoff where humanity will hand off control to transformative AI at some point.”
In his seminal essay, Machines of Loving Grace, CEO Dario Amodei contemplates:
“It could be a capitalist economy of AI systems, which then give out resources (huge amounts of them, since the overall economic pie will be gigantic) to humans based on some secondary economy of what the AI systems think makes sense to reward in humans (based on some judgment ultimately derived from human values).”
Are you prepared to receive your “resources” from an AI system, based on criteria it determines? The full title of the poem Dario borrowed the title from is "All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace." Do you want to be "watched over" by AI?
If Anthropic's founders believe that the ultimate destination is the transfer of human control to AI, the world deserves to know. Washington, D.C. deserves to know. American citizens deserve to know. And if that belief informs Anthropic's corporate objectives, it belongs in the Risk Factors section of its S-1. It isn't there today.
I am decidedly anti-handoverism. I'm not here to tell you what your view should be. But I believe anyone making consequential decisions about AI—especially those drafting, advocating for, or enacting AI regulation—should be required to disclose where they stand on this fundamental question.
A wonderfully thoughtful piece on the subject by @RuxandraTeslo:
https://t.co/9rdlBoNX5j
From Platonic dualists and the Gnostics to ascetic Christian theologians, the human body and human faculties beyond reason — like emotion, embodiment, and intuition — were seen as inconvenient and often unpleasant realities of this flawed earthly existence, rather than beautiful aspects of a full-spectrum human existence. This blinkered approach to the human continued with science, which until recently has mostly ignored emotions, the mind-body connection, and phenomenal consciousness. This is why AI is so dehumanizing, and why the AI consciousness debate is so confused and so polarized. AI is engineered from within a worldview that knows remarkably little about what it means to be a feeling, embodied human—and that routinely elevates narrow technical brilliance over the wider wisdom of human maturity.
I find it frustrating that AI people fundamentally don't understand how science works.
Science has never been roadblocked by computation.
Let me give you a concrete example. Nucleic acids (DNA, RNA) were first discovered by the Swiss physician-chemist Friedrich Miescher in 1869. He made an extract from white blood cell nuclei. The extraction technique was one that typically extracted proteins from a cell. But in this case, Miescher noticed that his extracts contained no sulfur. (Proteins contain sulfur.) Also, strangely, the extracts contained phosphorus (something NOT found in proteins). He called his extracts "nuclein" (to distinguish them from "protein").
Miescher measured the pH of his extracts. They were acidic. We now call the macromolecules his discovered "nucleic acids."
There is no way computation would have predicted Miescher's discovery of nucleic acids nor would it have helped Miescher in any way.
For many years (1869 to 1944), proteins were thought to be the genetic material. No one believed nucleic acids were complex enough to encode phenotypes. Work by Avery and his colleagues (in 1944) showed that DNA, not proteins, must in fact be the genetic material. The Avery discovery did not hinge on computation in any way.
In 1950, Austrian biochemist Erwin Chargaff discovered that the amount of guanine in DNA equals the amount of cytosine, and also adenine equals the amount of thymine. This discovery did not hinge on computation and would not have been made easier by AI.
People who think AI will "solve biology" do not understand how scientific discovery works.
Thank you for asking the original question.
@GaryMarcus I think any civilization that has colonialism, an Age of Reason enamored with the machine metaphor, an obsession with rationality at the exclusion of all else, and a tendency to confuse the map for the territory will go through it.
@Scribe419@superwuster Reviewing "The Path Away from the Law", 110 Harv. L. Rev. 1039 (1997) for the first time in 25 years I'm realizing he was mildly critical of the idea
@PJVogt Thank you for producing one of the better podcast episodes about this saga so far. It also inspired me to finally understand Nvidia's chip lines, and which were subject to export restrictions when
@atmoio It's the same situation with Anthropic and their "independent" AI consciousness research orgs like @eleosai, as I detailed here https://t.co/JkEOAs13Aa