A huge percentage of my life is spent avoiding crowds. Avoiding fashionable ideas, investing in underpriced assets, finding cool places that aren't deluged with tourists — they're all variants of the same thing. Whenever I find myself in a crowd, I feel something is wrong.
@gfodor I think real hardware overhang looks something like the discovery of x-rays. Total time between learning they exist and being used in a doctor's office? Two weeks
It might be worth noting that currently just under 50% of the population in the US has a job, full or part time. Most people aren't working - too young, too old, or other reasons. For people 16 and up, the percentage has come down from 65%->59% over the last 30 years as boomers have been retiring. I wonder how fast that percentage can change before things get crazy
That's a good point. That may be different in the theoretical and experimental sciences as well. I think it's still fairly difficult (although certainly not unheard of) to have multiple first author papers in experimental physics before coming to graduate school, but I'd believe that students have more research experience in any case and are more valuable from the outset now than they used to be.
Further leaving the original topic of discussion, what do you feel like the purpose of graduate school is for you or similar students, given that you already felt that you were mostly standing on your own coming in?
I would love for roon to be right, but I feel fairly confident that he is wrong with regards to physics because I don't think that the AI labs or their AIs will be able to imagine, design, or build the experiments needed to make big advances in physics
I would be so excited if they can actually do this, so someone follow up in a few years if I'm wrong. I'd be thrilled.
And if they're *only* able to produce a purely theoretical revolution of understanding on par with general relativity, quantum mechanics, nuclear structure, quantum electrodynamics, the cosmic microwave background, or anything like that, and it's validated by experiment or observation elsewhere, I will be similarly impressed
I remember when I spoke to my NSF grant administrator for the GRFP and she told me that I wouldn't be a full time employee when I was finished with my coursework because "I would spend 50% of my time doing research for my PI, and the other 50% of my time doing my own independent research" and I thought to myself "Do you know how this works?"
It was interesting that we received a large portion of our salary during the summer, because we were considered full time employees, and then we would "go back to school" in the fall and have our paid hours reduced to 50%, even though nothing whatsoever changed
@paulg It's a nice soundbite, but despite that being a literal quote, I think he's saying something closer to "the design part of hardware engineering is software engineering." And that's fair! But construction & testing (not to mention supply chain) are still significantly different
@AStrasser116 Great list! As a scientist, I've had similar thoughts. It does make me wonder if many of the most important things we can do here (like the corporal works of mercy) would be present in some manner in heaven. Or would those things just be memories?