🚨This is why the Conversion Practices Bill is so dangerous🚨
Two trans activists have published an attempted hit job on me, in which they enlisted people to contact me and pose as concerned relatives seeking therapy for a distressed child.
They have used my email responses to allege that I am a “conversion therapist”.
Of course, there is no basis for this allegation whatsoever (you can read the email yourself to see this).
Shockingly, they also claim that I am “genocidal”.
And, as if I didn’t need further evidence that this is gutter journalism, I have discovered they have doctored some of the wording in the email I sent to this prospective client (which again I can prove).
If this is happening to therapists working in this space before legislation has come in to force, just imagine how chilling things will be once the monstrous Bill is law.
https://t.co/ntUHVVQ8YQ
But @kathleen_stock1 and @JoPhoenix1 - inter alia - were subject to 'organised campaigns of harassment' which the respective union branches of @UCU at Sussex and the OU encouraged and took part in. @DrJoGrady was deeply complicit in that harassment.
The hypocrisy is as obvious as it is disgusting.
Why do trans identifying adults require so much external validation for their trans identity?
Answers to include reference to: Childhood
Bowlby, Ainsworth: Attachment Theory
Winnicott: True Self/False Self
Erikson, Marcia: Identity Development and Foreclosure
AI may be used!
Best answer will be reposted. And best will include internal coherence and brevity.
This man is supposed to be the chair of equalities. Yet his idea of equality is to pass laws preventing loving parents from questioning a confused child who has been duped into believing a medical pathway - involving badly-evidenced hormonal interventions and irreversible surgeries - can deliver happiness or ‘authenticity’.
This man clearly thinks equality means allowing men into women’s safe spaces because, according to trans ideology, any man who declares himself a woman magically becomes one, and somehow becomes less of a threat, despite statistics showing a different truth.
I dearly hope voters wake up to the fact that the modern Labour Party is no longer defined by the dignity of work and opposition to the exploitation of workers. It is a grievance party that will throw its weight behind any movement that claims to be progressive, however regressive it is in reality.
It is a party that risks changing our society beyond recognition, promoting morally bankrupt values that threaten to unpick the very fabric of Britain and turn it into an Orwellian dystopia.
That might sound like hyperbole, but we already live in a country where Labour politicians are enabling vulnerable children - many of whom would otherwise grow out of their gender distress given time, support and love - to make irreversible decisions they may bitterly regret. Some will eventually turn around and ask: ‘Why didn’t somebody stop me from ruining my life?’
At the same time, politicians from a party once fiercely proud of its promotion of women’s rights are now totally committed to putting the demands of cross-dressing men first.
It horrifies me every time I see a post like this. They’re showing us who they are. We should believe them.
You might be a former leftie like me, but however much you dislike the Tories, the deleterious consequences of supporting Labour for both children and women’s rights cannot simply be ignored.
Ask yourself, if ideologues like this man are in places of power for a prolonged period, where will they take us? And just how much harm are they capable of causing?
Thanks, @Glinner. I hope you don’t mind me going back over some of the history. It shows some of the difficulties we’ve faced: our attempts to understand and protect young people have been misrepresented as bigotry, and honest dialogue has been shut down since the beginning.
Sue @sueevansprotect blew the whistle in 2005. She was warning that young people with serious comorbid problems were being rushed into a medical pathway with very little psychological assessment. David Taylor, then medical director at the Tavistock, asked Jim McKeith to investigate GIDS. Taylor wrote a highly critical report in 2006. I was part of the senior management team, but its findings were never discussed there. The Trust buried it.
In 2019, I resigned as a governor because I realised history was in danger of repeating itself. The Trust was trying to bury David Bell’s report, which raised similar concerns to those Sue had raised in 2005.
That year I spoke alongside Stephanie Davies-Arai @cwknews and others at a House of Lords event organised by Posie Parker’s group, Standing for Women @StandingforXX and sponsored by Lord Moonie @Moonie_l Afterwards, we met in the pub to discuss what to do when there is a failure of medical authority. That was where the plan was hatched for Sue and Mrs A, the mother of an autistic child on the GIDS waiting list, to bring a judicial review. Sue put the case together with Paul Conrathe. Keira Bell @KBtheYoungOG was initially a witness in the case and later became a claimant.
While I was being interviewed by the Panorama team about GIDS in 2019, I told them about Taylor’s report. Hannah Barnes @hannahsbee was part of the team and later obtained the report through a Freedom of Information request. In September 2020, NHS England commissioned Hilary Cass @Hilary_Cass to lead an independent review of gender identity services for children and young people. The review account is @TheCassReview.
Newsnight reported on Taylor’s report on 1 October 2020. It showed that many of the concerns later raised in David Bell’s report had already been identified: a lack of critical clinical thinking, too little attention to the possible downsides of treatment, and little interest in follow-up or research. In other words, there was a lack of appropriate clinical curiosity. The High Court later ruled in the claimants’ favour, but the Court of Appeal overturned that ruling in 2021.
As I argued in my first paper, “Freedom to Think”, published in the Psychiatric Bulletin, clinicians need to be free to think, even when a patient may fear that thinking will introduce doubt and conflict. Thinking can be painful. It can bring anxiety and doubt in place of certainty. But it is crucial because it also protects us against misadventure. The wish to shut down discussion and thought is still represented in the Conversion Practices Bill. We are still fighting to bring to light what is happening in this clinical area and to stop a Bill that would have a chilling effect on clinicians’ ability to explore and thoroughly assess what is going on with these young people. @SexMattersOrg@Transgendertrd@genspect@CanSG_org #ConversionPracticesBill
1/ One of the ideas mooted at committee today was a "one line clarification" in the conversion bill to say "this bill is not intended to catch good parents" or similar.
With great respect to the legal witnesses, this cannot work as a matter of criminal law. I'll explain why.
Proud to work for a newspaper with a such a clear understanding of this hideous medical, legal, political, educational, paediatric, psychiatric and social scandal @thetimes
Conversion Practices Bill uses a sledgehammer to crack a nut
https://t.co/sOIzTZH6GF
It's a significant flaw in the pro Conversion argument that they can't cite a single case, study or opinion from the police or CPS regarding a case where they were stuck for something to charge. The fact we are using Stonewall (lol) "evidence" is just ridiculous for legislation.
“According to the Cabinet Office, the Stonewall survey is the best available data. The reality is instead that the Stonewall survey provides the best available data on how likely people are to fabricate claims of conversion practices if it suits their goals.”
Cass is the most eminent pediatrician in the UK and must keep repeating a fact that ought to have been dispositive of the question of whether chemically castrating tens of thousands of children was a thinkable act with no effect on whether they went ahead and did it. The context in which she repeats this impotent fact today is an attempt to avert a legislative push by the British Parliament to make it a crime to disagree that a daughter is a son or a son a daughter if the child believes they are the sex they are not.
We need to stop regarding political opinions as sitting on a one-dimensional “left/right” continuum. You may despise Donald Trump (as I do) while agreeing with him on one issue (as I do). Each one of us is better seen as a point in MULTI-dimensional space. The number of dimensions is open to discussion, as is their interaction with each other, and the feasibility of reducing their number because of correlations. Moreover, we need to form our opinions on each issue separately, in its own right, instead of identifying with a “tribe”, especially a tribe with its own social-media “echo chamber.”
Congratulations to SEGM founding board member Julia Mason, MD, whose article on puberty blockers and the Dutch protocol is one of Physician's Weekly's 10 most-read features of 2026.
She argues that blockers may worsen gender dysphoria and that the supporting studies are flawed. ⬇️
Among Hilary Cass’s bombshells in today’s #ConversionBill committee was this key point: that transgender identity & sexual orientation are different. Lumping them together as if they’re the same kind of thing is one of the aspects of the Bill that makes it a conceptual mess./1>
Against the Conversion Practices Bill:
-Therapists
-Doctors
-Teachers
-Parents
-Religious Ministers
-LGB Charities
-Free Speech Organisations
-Women’s Rights Groups
-Baroness Hilary Cass
For the Conversion Practices Bill:
-Stonewall
There WILL be private prosecutions, no ifs, no buts.
The Attorney General, if we have a rational government and a sensible, non-gender ideologue as our AG, would step in & enter a "nolle prosequi" but why leave it to chance.
This is a bad bill, promoted by deeply stupid people.
“There is only one cure for adolescence, and this is the passage of time and the passing on of the adolescent into the adult state.”
Donald Winnicott (1962) explains why there is NO justification for the misuse of puberty blockers on our children. Let the child grow and become adult. Let them develop the tools within themselves to manage their feelings about their own bodies and their sex.
As it’s Trans Awareness Week, here is a trans fact I think we should all be aware of.
Most trans-identifying men are heterosexual; that is, they’re sexually attracted to women. These men go around calling themselves lesbians, and they do expect real lesbians to willingly sleep with them. These men have invaded lesbian spaces both online and IRL so pervasively that it has become impossible for real lesbians to use dating apps, go to lesbian events, or discuss lesbian issues without encountering them. Decades after lesbian liberation, we’re once again having to tiptoe around, trying not to offend men by saying “no” the wrong way.
- The male desire to crossdress isn’t caused by having a “female gender identity,” it’s caused by a sexual fetish called autogynephilia, in which a man becomes aroused by the idea of himself as a woman. In online trans spaces, this phenomenon is referred to as “gender euphoria,” and men write about getting “euphoria boners” when people “she/her” them, or use their new feminine name.
-A person is more likely to have multiple sexual fetishes than he is to have just one; exhibitionism and voyeurism are most common, but pedophilia, sadism, and masochism are also commonly found alongside autogynephilia.
-Having gender dysphoria doesn’t mean a person doesn’t have autogynephilia. In the overwhelming majority of cases, the autogynephilia causes the gender dysphoria.
The entire premise of transgenderism is “I want to be something I’m not, so everyone around me must pretend that I am that thing in order to protect me from the heartbreak of reality. It’s no different than if I were to insist that everyone has to pretend I’m Danaerys Targaryen because I’d rather be the beautiful young Queen of Westeros than a middle aged American cop. What we are and what we want to be are often two very different things, and only the very unwell would claim that you can reconcile them by blackmailing everyone around you into pretending that they’re the same.
@bbcnickrobinson just made an almighty pig’s ear of his Radio 4 Today programme interview with Dr Hilary Cass.
Firstly, he seemed confused about the difference between sex and gender identity. Then he failed to get to grips with the fundamental problem with the draft conversion practices bill.
The controversy centres on trans identity. Nobody is seriously arguing that people should be subjected to abusive conversion practices because they’re lesbian, gay or bisexual. The concern is that parents or therapists could find themselves confronted with a child who believes they were somehow ‘born in the wrong body’, yet risk falling foul of the law simply for questioning that belief or urging caution.
Hilary Cass managed to highlight some of the key issues, but Robinson, by using the term ‘LGBTQ+ community’, was doing what the BBC has done for years: lumping lesbian, gay and bisexual people together with those who identify as trans, as well as those who describe themselves as queer, which, in my view, is more a political movement than a sexual orientation. And what does the ‘+’ stand for Nick? Any ideas?
‘LGB’ and ‘TQ+’ are groups with different concerns, and treating them as a single, homogeneous community obscures the very issues that journalists should be examining.
The BBC has to do far better on this subject. But there’s precious little sign that it intends to.
Hannah Barnes' interview with an affected parent exposes fatal flaws in draft Conversion Practices Bill.
@wesstreeting once said that reading @hannahsbee's 'Time to Think' led him to reject Stonewall's positions of opposing sex-based rights and the Cass Review.
We deeply hope @bphillipsonMP, @10DowningStreet & the members of the Bill Scrutiny Committee will read Hannah's article & realise, before it's too late, that this Stonewall-influenced draft bill would reverse progress made since the Cass Review.
1/
https://t.co/6PH6f6G7M7