We really are in a (temporary?) place where a combination of expertise and being able to work with AI allows people to do incredible things. It is no coincidence that people proving Millennium Problems have all been great mathematicians, the models can't (yet) do it on their own
@BenjaminPDixon I think you can argue that the job of mathematicians has not merely been to prove theorems true, and that, at this point, is all the Alpoge + Claude proof does at the moment. But I suspect now that a proof exists, we will likely see great strides in creating an interpretable one
@BenjaminPDixon I don’t think this is really fair. The AI company published a machine checkable proof for a statement of RH that has long since been vetted by many experts. That gives us pretty strong assurances that it’s correct and not merely a claim
@Vuk87696659@romlib_ I’m not sure you quite understand how theorem provers work? Roughly speaking the point is that you have to verify that the _statement_ being proved is correct and that the code compiles. The statement is not 170k pages (it is in fact something that was already in Mathlib)
@LinkofSunshine@SpecialPuppy1 But nonetheless it’s absolutely true that AI is enormously helpful in just putting in the work to formalize things that would have been monumental efforts to formalize by hand, absolutely wouldn’t deny that (and I have a GitHub repository with 200k lines of lean to prove it!)
@LinkofSunshine@SpecialPuppy1 Mathlib is quite opinionated on things like this for example. My experience with using agents in “prove this at all cost” mode vs a more curated approach is that you end up with formalizations that look drastically, drastically different
Vegans have to get vitamin B12 from artificial supplements, unlike meat-eaters, who get it from natural sources, like factory farmed animals whose feed is artificially supplemented with vitamin B12.
Fascinated by the Type of Guy who looks at schools today and thinks the main problem is “I think they’re a little too wishy washy on if murder is wrong”
Literally what the fuck is Mathew McConaughey taking about here. “Take the author out of it for a moment”
brother the first commandment starts with “I am your Lord thy God”
“Are there commandments where people out there are like ‘I disagree with that one’” YES the first ~four
Matthew McConaughey asks Joe Rogan: is there one of the Ten Commandments you disagree with?
Joe Rogan: I don't like mandating the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms. What about the Muslims, the Buddhists, the Hindus, all the other religions? If you say this is a Christian society, then you'd have a wall of religious texts in the high school.
Joe: James Talarico, a Texas state representative who's in seminary and very religious, opposes it. He thinks forcing it into classrooms will repel young people from Christianity. I don't know if he's right, but that's his argument.
Joe: If you want to teach about the Bible and what Jesus was saying, like treating everyone as your brother, fine. But if schools are publicly funded, I think religion should stay out. Imagine if every public school taught Islam and everyone had to bow five times a day. A Muslim parent seeing Christianity imposed would feel the same.
Matthew McConaughey: My hang-up is that we go to the author instead of the content. Is there anything in the Ten Commandments that you disagree with? Don't murder. Don't steal. Don't lie. Honor your parents.
Joe: I think they're pretty legit. They kind of nailed it, like the Constitution.
Matthew: Does anyone have a better suggestion for getting a child's mind going than those ten things? I'm seeing youth and adults spun out. People say, "I could pick your pocket if I got away with it. I don't feel guilty." Where's the ground? What can I rely on that's time-tested, that I can go to in the storm, in the dark on my own, no matter what AI changes?
Joe: If I were putting it in a school with non-religious people, some of it would give them pause. Not taking the Lord's name in vain, no other gods before me.
They agree the commandments hold up. They disagree about who should put them on the classroom wall.
@KelseyTuoc My primary use case is applied cryptography research
I primarily use Opus 5.5 and Mythos (now) 5.2. 5.2 is noticeably better than 5.1 however frankly I wish they would release an Opus analogue to what Mythos is to Fable. The bang for buck is just so much on Opus